A Maverick Organist Cuts Loose on a Christmas Standard

Monday, December 19, 2011 - 08:40 PM

Cameron Carpenter has done it again.

The supremely gifted, flamboyant organist offers another example of his remarkable technical and musical skills in a new recording and video of “Sleigh Ride.”

Carpenter made his recording earlier this month on the Marshall & Ogletree Opus 5 digital organ at Middle Collegiate Church in the East Village. There are many things to appreciate here, but let’s start with the most spectacular. Notice where Cameron plays the melody of “Sleigh Ride” when it first appears. Hint: Don’t look at his hands.

Now, it would be amazing enough if Cameron were playing that melody, which covers more than an octave, with his feet. But he doesn’t play it with his feet. He plays it with just his right foot. And while he’s doing that, his left foot is busy with the usual organist-feet duty of the bass notes. And he’s not – to use an expression – sitting on his hands during any of this, either. His “Sleigh Ride” is a very fair organ transcription of the original version for orchestra, but Carpenter also adds counter-melodies of his own here and there throughout the piece. You'll note that he’s often playing more than one manual, or keyboard, at a time, too, and constantly changing registrations – the combinations of organ sounds designated to be played on one manual or another.

If those sounds seem a little strange coming from a church organ, it’s because they aren’t church organ stops. They’re more typical of a theater organ, the instrument that accompanied silent movies a hundred years ago. Carpenter, who designed the Middle Collegiate instrument to include the theater organ stops, describes it as “another drop in the bucket of my argument for the supremacy of the digital organ.”

Carpenter told me that he began his serious organ studies at the American Boychoir School (ABS) in Princeton. At the time, Leroy Anderson’s famous work for orchestra -- which first appeared in 1949 on a Boston Pops recording -- became part of his repertory. “It was when I was there I arranged much music for organ, and the first things I started on were the pieces of Leroy Anderson – 40 or 50 of them.”

That school is part of the reason for this new recording. “As an alum of ABS, I’m terribly proud of what it has to offer and terribly concerned that its attendance is down; that it has taken several hits over the last decade," he said. "My first experience in Europe, my first international organ broadcast and solo recitals were with ABS.” So Carpenter has designated proceeds of the “Sleigh Ride” single on iTunes to go his choral alma mater.

You’re probably wondering about his snazzy shoes. “The shoes began life as Capezio Latin Oxfords, heavily modified. We’re in the midst of a total redesign of organ shoes. The shoes are a very important part of the playing, and it’s long been my feeling that organ shoes are spectacularly badly engineered for playing the organ. This shoe is a real dance shoe. It weighs almost nothing. It has an extended heel.”

And the sequins – or are they rhinestones? Not for this showman. “They’re neither sequins nor rhinestones," said Carpenter, who designs his own outfits. "They’re crystals; they’re Swarovski, so they’re coming from Austria. I find that crystals on the shoes not only improve visibility, but they’re very difficult to imitate without being totally obvious.”

If you’d like to see Cameron Carpenter and his crystal-studded organ shoes in person around New York, you’ll have to wait until 2012. Cameron lives in Berlin these days, and his next scheduled public appearance in the area is an April 29 concert in Prudential Hall at NJPAC in Newark.

In the meantime, if you’d like a couple of other examples of Carpenter’s virtuosity, see his transcription of Chopin’s Revolutionary Etude, in which he plays the left-hand piano part with only his feet. The video was made for his first Telarc recording three years ago. Or watch his 2007 performance of Sousa’s “The Stars and Stripes Forever,” playing the piccolo part with just his feet. You can hear the gasps of amazement from the audience when they realize what he’s doing. Both performances took place on the Marshall & Ogletree organ at Trinity Church in Manhattan.

Reactions to Carpenter’s organ-pedal pyrotechnics can be surprisingly strong. When I sent the “Sleigh Ride” video around to some friends, several of them replied by saying, “That’s incredible. I can hardly believe what I’m seeing.” Except they didn’t use those words. They used shorter, pithier, expressions of three or four syllables that we can’t possibly print on this family-oriented Web site. I did share them with Cameron, though, and he seemed quite pleased, saying, “I’ve always felt that organ-playing should inspire profanity whenever possible.”


More in:

Comments [12]

Don from Joliet. Illinois

Thanks Jeff
That has to be the best performance of that song on a pipe organ ever(or ever will be)made. He is a GREAT talent, the kind that may never come around again. We all hope it isn't, there needs to be more talented young people to continue keeping organ music alive unto the future. I wish him God speed in his future.

Dec. 28 2011 01:44 PM
Greg from NYC

YOU GO, BOY!!!!!

Dec. 23 2011 08:44 AM
bill from NJ from NJ

We heard Cameron at his Longwood Gardens performance earlier this year, and he "blew our socks off." Enjoyed his meet-the-audience walk-through before the concert. My son-in-law, who is an organ "fan," was estatic.

We are looking forward to his concert at NYPAC in April -- just purchased the tickets last night.

Dec. 22 2011 08:41 AM
Robert from Staten Island

Well as classical organist must thank Mendelssohn for bringing Bach back, we should thank you Mr. Murray for bringing back thumb down technique, which of course Cameron's technique has brought to a new level.

I am looking forward to Theater Organists adopting the new counter melody technique Cameron uses. Oh I forgot how about the melody technique.

Cameron has had many comments made about him, but the bottom line is that he is a wonderful musician with perhaps unmatched technique. Brovo!

Dec. 21 2011 03:28 PM
Shiv from New Jersey

Simply brilliant. A true talent.

Dec. 21 2011 03:15 PM

Thanx Jeff. Could you see him performing Hoedown! That would be interesting

Dec. 21 2011 10:42 AM
Lee from Germany

I am in absolute awe of both his transcriptions. However, after watching his Stars and Stripes arrangement I do not believe he used his feet at all for the famous piccolo solos, either the first or second time.

Dec. 21 2011 03:18 AM

Talk about "Pipe Dreams"! Cameron definitely deserves more air time, if he hasn't already gotten it. Thank you, Jeff.

Dec. 20 2011 05:35 PM
David from Flushing

Organists showing off their footwork goes way back in organ literature. There is a whole genre of theme and variations that were extremely popular in 19th century America. Audiences of the time very much appreciated themes they could recognize. Almost without exception, the next to the last variation included an elaborate pedal performance.

Hope-Jones included some odd stops in his church organs. The late organ in the Baptist Temple, Philadelphia, had a thunder sheet and tuned electric bells around the face of the balcony. Whether the thunder sheet punctuated fire and brimstone sermons remains unclear.

Dec. 20 2011 12:13 PM


Dec. 20 2011 12:09 PM

Thanks Jeff,
I great review for a very TALENTED artist. You turned me on to Cameron when his Revolutionary album came out and I've been a fan ever since. This dude is truely amazing. Concerning the shoes, maybe Cameron can make an arrangement of Glen Campbell's: RHINESTONE COWBOY! (I know, they're not rhinestones)
Best Wishes

Dec. 20 2011 08:38 AM

I wanna see this dude's rendition of Volumina!

Dec. 20 2011 01:13 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Follow WQXR 







About WQXR Blog

Read WQXR's coverage of classical music news, trends, commentary and more here at the WQXR Blog.