Naomi Lewin, WQXR Host
Naomi Lewin is the weekend host on WQXR, and host of the weekly podcast Conducting Business.
Alan Gilbert was right.
Last night, in one of the quietest parts of the final movement of a gorgeous New York Philharmonic performance of Mahler's Ninth, a cell phone started ringing ... and ringing, and ringing, and ringing. Alan Gilbert, who was on the podium in Avery Fisher Hall, glared in the direction of the phone, but it kept right on going. Then, the music got louder, and we all assumed that whoever owned the phone had done something about it. But minutes later, when the music got softer again the phone was still going (an iPhone marimba ringtone, which sounds like this):
"Usually, when there's a disturbance like this, it is best to ignore it," he said. "But this was so egregious…" And he was right. It was egregious. The audience clearly agreed, giving him wildly supportive applause.
After resuming the fourth movement of Mahler’s Ninth from an appropriate place, and bringing the symphony to its exquisite conclusion, Alan Gilbert left his hand in the air. The indication was clear: "Here. Enjoy the silence." And we did. Not a soul clapped until he began to lower his hand, at which point Maestro Gilbert and the Philharmonic enjoyed a heartfelt ovation -- for the music and the response.
Anyone who thinks this was an act of ego should give it another think. I was there. I don't know why the owner of the phone, or someone near the owner, did not get it to stop, but there was absolutely no way the music could have reasonably continued with that accompaniment. Bravo, Alan Gilbert. You were right.
What do you think of Alan Gilbert's response? Take our poll and leave a comment below: