The Pitfalls of Carrying Musical Instruments on Planes

Cellist Recalls 'State of Panic' After Checking Instrument

Monday, August 27, 2012

instrument passenger on a plane instrument passenger on a plane (dmuth/flickr)

U.S. airlines are more punctual and less likely to lose your bag than at any time in more than two decades, according to a recent Associated Press analysis of Bureau of Transportation data. Fewer than three suitcases per 1,000 passengers were reported lost, damaged or delayed from January through June, a record low.

But a recent spate of stories concerning musical instruments on airplanes suggests that the skies aren't always friendly for musicians. 

Paul Katz, a former member of the Cleveland Quartet, recently experienced a particularly dramatic incident involving his 1669 Andrea Guarneri cello and a flight from Calgary to Los Angeles operated by WestJet, which partners with American and Delta, among other carriers.

"I was even pre-boarded. I got the royal treatment,” Katz tells host Naomi Lewin in this podcast. Then one of the flight attendants came and told him the airline "had a policy that cellos were not allowed on board and that I’d have to leave. So that started a lot of shenanigans. I begged, I pleaded, I got mad, I got sad, I did everything." Eventually, Katz agreed to let the airline stow the cello in the luggage hold below the wing.

“As the plane took off, it was the bumpiest runway you could imagine," Katz continued. "Then we got up in the air and after a few minutes they discontinued beverage service because there was so much turbulence. At this point my imagination started going completely crazy. I was near a breakdown because I thought 'how could I have ever done this?' The stupidest thing I’ve ever done in my life was to give them my instrument.” (WestJet countered in a statement that "the seat and its restraint system are designed and rated for a person.")

The incident drew widespread attention after Katz wrote about it in an article for the Boston Globe, and it raised new questions of how airlines set their own rules about which musical instruments are allowed on board. Cellos are particularly problematic, not being able to fit in overhead bins and generally requiring their own seat.

This comes as the Paris-based International Federation of Musicians (FIM) has launched an online petition with the aim of persuading EU legislators to take action on the issue of musical instruments on planes. The organization, which represents 72 musicians' unions worldwide, is calling for Europe to follow the example of the US, which earlier this year introduced a uniform musical instrument policy for airlines.

Still, the "passenger bill of rights" which passed in congress in February is not without loopholes. As Rose Hirschel, the owner of the travel agency Musicians' Travel Services, explained, while the bill is a tremendous advance, “it has a stipulation for each carrier to judge whether each instrument is safe on the aircraft. It will help a lot but it certainly will not be a panacea.”

James H. Burnett III is a culture writer for the Boston Globe who recently examined the rules governing carry-on luggage. Considering Katz’s experience, he is not overly optimistic that the rules will become clearer. “Given that ultimately this is a government bureaucracy we’re seeing, which means more red tape wrapped around more red tape. So I don’t see any serious change in the near future."

Listen to the full discussion above - which includes tips on boarding the plane more quickly and smoothly - and share your thoughts below.

Guests:

  • Paul Katz, a professor of cello and chamber music, New England Conservatory and cellist in the Cleveland Quartet from 1969-1995
  • Rose Hirschel, owner, Musicians' Travel Services
  • James H. Burnett III, cultural reporter, Boston Globe

Tags:

More in:

Comments [10]

Robert Howe

I have travelled a lot with oboes, heckelphones (both carried with me), saxophones (altos and tenors go in the cargo) and telescopes (checked and carried). The musician has to take the initiative to protect his instrument. A costly, tough-as-nails carrying case for the Strad 'cello will protect it as well as, or better than, carrying it into the cabin. The problem really is seeing that it gets on to the correct plane.

Sep. 03 2012 05:02 PM
John J. Christiano from Franklin NJ

I would never put any wooden instrument in an airplane cargo hold. First of all, aircraft stowage is designed to maximize quantity in a given space. Understandable, since you are on a craft with a very finite amount of space. So....pack to the max! Who know what it'll be bumping up against.

Second, and I'm asking here, are air cargo holds conditioned spaces? Will the instrument be subject to temperatures and humidity outside of its normal environment? Will it need a week after arrival for re-string, tuning?

If I was carrying a Strad or Guarneri, I would not let it out of my sight. Buy that extra seat or go by train.

Sep. 02 2012 11:34 AM
beth from NYC

listened again--
you had me at "cello"

Aug. 31 2012 09:16 PM
Nancy B from NJ

A while back we were "asked" (directed?) to relinquish our bulkhead seats to accommodate a cellist and instrument. They had appeared to be comfortably settled in the triple seat behind us. Seems that their appropriate location should have been settled ahead of time.

Aug. 31 2012 03:14 PM
Barry Owen Furrer

And who was it that said "there's always room for cello?"

Aug. 30 2012 07:27 PM
Susie

Of course you did, John...but it was probably respectfully. The cellos in our family have their own frequent flyer accounts and
Usually get bulkhead seats, but can manage in the middle.

Aug. 30 2012 04:49 PM
John F from Morristown, NJ

On a recent flight from San Francisco to Newark, I was comfortably boarded in my favorite bulkhead window seat (which I had chosen months in advance) when I was asked to exchange seats with a cello in a middle seat further back in the cabin.
I respectively declined.

Aug. 30 2012 08:59 AM
Mat Dirjish from New York, NY

Airlines have never really been musical-instrument friendly. Their attitude is pretty "old school" in that they are in the people-shipping business. The task is to get humans to and from specific destinations safely with their non-delicate and non-volatile luggage. They most likely feel that if you need to move something fragile and/or valuable, use a responsible shipping carrier. You can expect more from your airline of choice, but don't be disappointed if they can't deliver.

Aug. 29 2012 10:28 AM
WQXR

@Beth: Listen to the podcast and you just might find out!

Aug. 28 2012 09:48 PM
beth

so.....what happened to the cello?
oh, and who cares?

Aug. 28 2012 09:40 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Follow WQXR 

Sponsored

About Conducting Business

WQXR looks deeper into the issues affecting the classical music landscape. 

Conducting Business is hosted by Naomi Lewin and produced by Brian Wise.

subscribe to Conducting Business

Listen to Stitcher

Feeds