The First Annual Excellence in Opera Awards (AKA The Freddies)

Tuesday, December 17, 2013 - 12:00 AM

Irene Theorin in the title role of Strauss's 'Elektra' at the Paris Opera Irene Theorin in the title role of Strauss's 'Elektra' at the Paris Opera (© Charles Duprat / OnP)

I have heard so many opera lovers complain about what they perceive as the sorry state of the art form that I decided to conclude 2013 by citing many of the excellent achievements in opera I have witnessed this year. 

The low point of this operatic year, and young century, was the death of the New York City Opera. What I found most appalling is that I seemed to be one of the very few people to broach the issue of how to save the NYCO. Most everyone else, from government to finance to many in the opera world, were just too willing to let this precious company expire like Manon Lescaut in the so-called deserts of Louisiana, alone, lost and abandoned.

But there was a lot of excellence in 2013. It may seem strange—but it is necessary—to point out that I have seen and heard every performance that entered my consideration for a Freddie (a practice not always observed by competition juries). This year I attended 104 opera performances. The theater I have frequented the most is, not surprisingly, the Metropolitan Opera. However, in 2013 I attended performances by 35 different companies. Herewith, the recipients of the Freddies—the 2013 Excellence in Opera Awards:


Sustained Excellence in Performance. No artist can match the achievements of soprano Patricia Racette, whom I saw this year in seven leading roles. She appeared as Leonora in Il Trovatore at the Met; Manon Lescaut at the Washington National Opera;  Madame Lidoine in Dialogues des Carmélites at the Met;  Il Prigioniero at the New York Philharmonic; Dolores Claiborne (San Francisco Opera); Margherita in Mefistofele (San Francisco Opera); Tosca at the Met. She learned Dolores Claiborne in a very short period of time, while rehearsing and performing in Mefistofele, replacing Dolora Zajick and saving a world premiere. I am very much looking forward to her first Met Maddalena in Andrea Chénier starting March 24.


Best Individual Performance, Male Singer: Ferruccio Furlanetto, Murder in the Cathedral, San Diego Opera. This artist takes total command of a stage through his splendid voice, acting and engagement with roles. This is not a question of hogging attention but that his gifts draw you to him. His performance as Thomas à Becket made a real case for the worthiness of Pizzetti’s 1958 opera. I am looking forward to the Italian bass as Massenet’s Don Quixote at the Canadian Opera in Toronto this May. [Honorable mention: Anthony Dean Griffey as Peter Grimes, St. Louis Symphony at Carnegie Hall; Jonas Kaufmann as Don Carlo in Salzburg; Peter Mattei as Amfortas and René Pape as Gurnemanz in Parsifal at the Met.]


Female Singer: Anja Harteros as Elisabetta in Don Carlo at the Salzburg Festival (right). Because the soprano cancelled the previous three times I had tickets to hear her in an opera, I gasped when she actually appeared onstage in Salzburg. I gasped many more times thanks to her gorgeous singing, affecting acting and remarkable chemistry with Jonas Kaufmann in the title role. For me, Harteros has been the gold standard in recent years of each role (Donna Anna, Violetta, Elsa, Elisabetta) I have seen her in. [Honorable mention: Cecilia Bartoli as Norma in Salzburg; Joyce DiDonato as Maria Stuarda at the Met; Christine Goerke as the Dyer’s Wife in Die Frau ohne Schatten at the Met; Karita Mattila as Marie in Wozzeck at the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden.]


Star-making Performance

Male: Michael Fabiano in I Lombardi alla Prima Crociata, Opera Orchestra of New York (April 6). The tenor wowed the audience with his golden-age style singing.

Female: Elza van den Heever in Maria Stuarda as Queen Elizabeth I. This formidable young South African soprano went all out in her Met debut and was a wonderful match for Joyce DiDonato in the title role.


Prick Up Your Ears: Sometimes we see and hear familiar artists in new and gratifying ways. Both Jennifer Check as Elisabeth and Jennifer Larmore as Eboli at the Caramoor Festival’s French-language version of Don Carlos in July revealed unexpected gifts that I hope opera companies will capitalize on.


Conducting, Individual Performance: Antonio Pappano’s Don Carlo at the Salzburg Festival was so clear, vibrant, fresh, profound and alive to dramatic moments as well as narrative arc that one heard this glorious score as if for the first time. [Honorable Mention: Harry Bicket, Giulio Cesare at the Met; Christian Thielemann, Lohengrin, Dresden; Philippe Jordan, Elektra in Paris; David Robertson, Peter Grimes, St. Louis Symphony at Carnegie Hall]


Comeback of the year: James Levine, of course. This fact is no less gratifying because it is obvious. His conducting with the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra in concert on Carnegie Hall (May 19), Così fan tutte and Falstaff made one feel all is right with the world.


Opera Orchestra: Hands down, the Metropolitan Opera. This ensemble is leagues ahead of every other and is the essential reason why it is exciting to hear opera at the Met.


Opera Chorus: Tie: the Metropolitan Opera and Teatro alla Scala. The Met’s chorus, expertly guided by Donald Palumbo, is as musical as it is versatile. For Italian repertory, La Scala’s chorus brings remarkable depth and connection to words and music.


New Production: Tie: Parsifal at Met and Elektra at the Paris Opera. See Stage Direction award below.


Revival of a ProductionDialogues des Carmelites at the Met in May. John Dexter’s perfect production was brought back with a fine cast, conductor (Louis Langrée) and a sense of purpose. A shame it was only given three performances.


Opera in Concert: Peter Grimes. David Robertson splendidly led the St. Louis Symphony and Chorus and a perfect cast at Carnegie Hall on November 22, the centennial of Britten’s birth.


Concert performance of Non-Operatic Music by an Opera Composer: Gianandrea Noseda led Maria Agresta, Daniela Barcellona, Gregory Kunde and Kyle Ketelson in Rossini’s Stabat Mater at the Mostly Mozart Festival, Lincoln Center, August 13. Unforgettable artistry by all involved.


Recital Era La Notte (Nov. 14 at Lincoln Center’s White Lights Festival) was not a recital in the strictest sense but an hour of concert arias and scenes sung and acted by the wondrous Anna Caterina Antonacci. Her connection to, and expression of, the music of Monteverdi and other early Italian composers were so profound that it prompted Anthony Tommasini in The New York Times to encourage the Metropolitan Opera to engage her immediately to sing whatever she wants. I expressed this sentiment in June 2011 and would propose that she sing Cherubini’s Medea.


Stage Direction: Tie: François Girard, Parsifal at the Met, and Robert Carsen, Elektra at the Paris Opera. Both drew their ideas for acting, movement and, I believe, design from the music and the libretto. This should be the normal approach, but most directors treat the text like a play and have little feeling for the music, as if it were something to get around. These two productions were so thoroughly inspired by music that they gave an unmatched level of thrills. Elektra is compact and intense while Parsifal is long and opulently emotional. Both require the same precision and openness to feeling, and that is what these stagings had. Both had a single directorial choice I would have asked to change if I were in charge, but those choices were informed by taste and intelligence rather than gimmickry. [I should note that Carsen’s Falstaff, new at the Met, was excluded from consideration because I saw and loved it in London in 2012. The same applies to Ambrogio Maestri, its brilliant star.]


Design: Scenery: Michael Levine for both Parsifal at the Met and Elektra at the Paris Opera. I was impressed to discover that my two favorite productions had the same designer. Both were at once modern and timeless, and not overly literal, providing an ideal context for these stories to be told. Costumes: John Macfarlane for Maria Stuarda at the Met (right). Lighting: Robert Carsen and Peter van Praet, Elektra in Paris. On a dark set, the specificity of the use of light introduced details that would suddenly capture the eye and then, just as suddenly, vanish. It made the storytelling absolutely riveting while never overwhelming the music and the acting.


Small Company Performance: Loft Opera Company—Don Giovanni in May and Le Nozze di Figaro in November. This is the most exciting little company I have encountered in a while. Performances are done with limited means but great intelligence and seriousness in a loft in the Gowanus Canal area of Brooklyn. Audiences, mostly quite young, sit on benches, drink Brooklyn Beer and are surrounded by the performers. The secret to Loft Opera’s success is that they take the music, words and dramaturgy as composer and librettist intended. In so doing, these operas become more relevant and pleasurable than any gimmicky concept could offer. They will perform La Bohème in the last two weeks of February.


Operas new to me: Where there is life, there is hope. All of these deserve commendation: Kevin Puts's Silent Night (Opera Company of Philadelphia, February); George Benjamin’s Written on Skin (Royal Opera, Covent Garden, March); Luigi dalla Piccola’s Il Prigioniero (New York Philharmonic, June); Tobias Picker’s Dolores Claiborne (San Francisco Opera, September); Mark-Antony Turnage’s Anna Nicole (New York City Opera, September); Nico Muhly’s Two Boys (Metropolitan Opera, October).


Most insightful comment I heard this year “An opera production should look the way the music sounds.” --Lady Valerie Solti


Special Freddie to audiences who continue to believe in and support live opera performances rather than hearing them in cinemas, on the computer, DVDs and other media. Opera is a live art form meant to be seen and heard in a theater. Make it one of your resolutions for 2014 to attend more opera performances wherever you live and travel.

Photos: 1) Anja Harteros as Elisabetta in Don Carlo at the Salzburg Festival (© Charles Duprat/OnP) 2) Parsifal (Ken Howard/Metropolitan Opera); 3) Maria Stuarda (Ken Howard/Metropolitan Opera).


More in:

Comments [13]

Anna Mills from NYC

Dear Mr. Plotkin,

I have been enjoying your insight into the world of opera and your delightful commentary for many years and I thank you.

"Freddies" is a splendid idea!

There is one point I would like to bring to your attention : you have never mentioned the Children's Artistic Chorus in any of the opera houses. These little artist work extremely hard as they have a full time job- school, and than they have another - opera. Constant auditions, heavy rehearsal schedules, long hours, missed school breaks; the list goes on and on. I speak from experience, as my daughter has been a member of the Met's Children's Chorus for almost 10 years now, and I have seen how committed all of these kids are and the sacrifices they willingly make. They are one of the hardest working group of people you will ever meet, yet they are rarely mentioned , let alone recognized for their wonderful work. I also believe that the Children's chorus master deserves special recognition as well. I am sure that all of the above applies to all Children's chorus members in all opera houses.

With kindest regard always,

Anna Mills

Mar. 14 2014 09:42 AM
LJK, New Jersey from New Jersey

What about the Pillsbury Dough Boy for a Freddy that would work well. If the shoe fits?

Dec. 27 2013 07:38 PM
Charles Fischbein from Front Royal, Va.

So now you name awards after yourself. I know what an "oscar" looks like, I imagine a (Freddie) would be about ten inches tall rather round with a distended belly, and a scarf draped around it, and a mouth dripping pasta sauce. Sort of like the old Bob's Big Boy they used in front of their burger joints. The image makes me laugh about as much as your self importance. However good health for the New Year, and God Speed, Charles Fischbein
Back to commercial free music on SiriusXM

Dec. 27 2013 09:54 AM
Fred Plotkin

Dear Ms. Bertino, I only considered performances I actually heard and I did not hear the Macbeth. The last time I heard RIccardo Muti conduct an opera was Simon Boccanegra in Rome in late 2012. The Freddies were only given for what I heard in 2013.

Dec. 21 2013 01:43 PM
mary bertino from michiagn

What about the Chicago Symphony's Orchestrata's performance of Verdi's MacBeth, Muti conducting????

Dec. 21 2013 12:50 PM
Fred Plotkin

Gentile Signor D'Amico, You are fortunate to live in Brooklyn, where there is live opera at a very fair price. I would start with Loft Opera, which won a Freddie for best small opera company. They do wonderful performances with talented young singers and the price of a ticket is $15. They will be doing La Bohéme in late February. Vertical Opera company performs in Brooklyn, and there are others too, many at prices equal to or less than the $25 to see an HD screening. I do hope that you will support these excellent companies in your borough. They are what keeps opera vibrant. I am mindful that I am fortunate to be able to travel to see opera for my work, yet I always encourage readers to attend live performances where they reside. My writing at Operavore has a worldwide readership and I do my best to cover the art form not only in New York, where I proudly live, but any place where good opera is performed. Grazie, buone feste e buon ascolto....Federico

Dec. 20 2013 12:19 PM
Pietro D'Amico from Brooklyn, NY

Dear Mr. Plotkin. Perhaps one day you will find that you have grown older. And maybe you will not become richer. You might find that you can no longer travel prudently or in comfort to Milano or Manhattan - or even to your local opera company. Maybe, then, you will lengthen the recipient list of your "Special Freddie" award to include those people who enjoy and support opera in whatever way they are able to. Sincerely (and knowingly), Pietro

Dec. 19 2013 02:12 PM

Get back to me next year, when (if) this is an ANNUAL blog post. It can't be annual until next year's appears.

Dec. 19 2013 04:00 AM
Fred Plotkin

Correction, Judy in Florida: The excellent opera company is in SARASOTA (not Saratoga)

Dec. 18 2013 12:22 AM
Fred Plotkin from New York

To Judy in Florida, I am not trying to discourage anyone from seeing opera at movie theaters, but there are several important reasons why it would be great if you could try to see live opera. Florida has many opera companies from Miami to Jacksonville to Pensacola. There is an excellent festival in Saratoga and other small companies doing important work. So, wherever you live, you are not all that far if you want to try. But there are other reasons too. Live opera engages the attendee in ways HD never can. First, the sound is always much better. You experience the live human voice and musical instruments in ways that electronic transmissions of every kind can never achieve. Then, when you attend a live performance, you decide what you look at and where you give your attention and focus. Also, frankly, HDs from the big opera companies in NYC, London, Vienna, Milan and elsewhere, while great, are having the effect of marginalizing local opera companies. Several important companies around the nation, including the one in Orlando, have succumbed to the competition. Sad to say, many people who go to HD no longer attend live opera on a regular basis, depriving local companies of audiences and income. Certainly there is a big dropoff of subscribers to the Met from the NYC metropolitan area and it has been alarming. By supporting your local or nearby company by purchasing tickets to a live performance, you are sustaining the art form and also providing work for opera singers, mostly American. And it enables local companies to do interesting repertory. The Florida Grand Opera in Miami just did "Mourning Becomes Electra" with the great Lauren Flanigan. Another way to think about it: Look at what Amazon did to local book and recording stores and how culturally depleting (as well as bad for local economies) these closures have been. Places where people gather for culture, whether in big urban centers or small communities, are places that give flavor and character and texture to the places we live in. Also, if you travel at all, look into what opera might be on in the places you are going to and attend a performance in those places. Not just in Italy, France or Germany, but Texas, Utah, Minnesota, Pennsylvania, Alaska, Hawaii and all kinds of other places where you might not expect there to be opera. You will enjoy it, and you will help sustain the art form in ways that HD attendance simply cannot do.

Dec. 18 2013 12:20 AM
Judy from Florida

We who live in the hinterlands do not have access to opera companies, so we do go to the opera at the cinema, both to appreciate operas new to us and to see old favorites again. Otherwise, we would not see this art form at all. And I like to think that we play our part in helping to support the opera companies that perform these live events that we get to see remotely. You might want to be a little more inclusive in your comments.

Dec. 17 2013 04:09 PM
Madison from Manhattan

I,too,loved the Met's Parsifal but largely for the magnificent cast. I felt that most of the first act looked like a 1958 Madison Ave.commercial for Arrow shirts. Why the Knights of the Holy Grail were dressed like that eludes me.On the other hand,we should be grateful it didn't sink to the unwatchable perverseness of the Met's present Rigoletto,Faust,Traviata and Ballo en Maschera."An opera production should look the way the music sounds",indeed.

Dec. 17 2013 12:54 PM
meche from Manhattan

I love the idea of "Freddies"! Of all your commendations I was most delighted to learn that you enjoyed the LOFT Opera as much as I did. I gave them a great review on

Dec. 17 2013 01:48 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Follow WQXR 







About Operavore


Operavore is WQXR's digital 24/7 audio stream and devoted to Opera. The Operavore blog features breaking news, expert commentary and reviews by writers Fred Plotkin, David Patrick Stearns, Amanda Angel and others. The music stream features a continuous, carefully programmed mix of classic and contemporary opera recordings.

Follow Operavore