Four Ways of Performing a Mad Scene

Saturday, September 03, 2011 - 12:52 PM

Mad scenes abound in opera. Tonight, the Met's Summer HD Festival continues with Mussorgsky's Boris Godunov, offering one of the meatiest manic moments for the bass-baritone (here, René Pape). Tomorrow, the granddaddy of all addled arias takes place, however, with Lucia di Lammermoor, starring Natalie Dessay and Joseph Calleja.

My love for Lucia is no secret. And one of the most amazing things about this opera is when it comes to a full stop for an ethereal scena that can be interpreted in so many ways, making it Exhibit A when people wonder why opera fans own so many different recordings of the same work. With that in mind, I tried my own crazy experiment, asking several sopranos what goes through their own heads as they come undone in the role of this Highland head case. Read on for their insights.

Wendy Baker

“Of all of the music I have been blessed to sing, performing the mad scene from Lucia is by far the most incredible musical experience I’ve ever had. As she walks on stage, the music that is played speaks to every part of my being. For that moment you are crazed, and all of the pressure from everyone is gone. You are now with your one true love. Everyone in the ballroom is staring at you and your audience becomes an extension of those watching you in the ballroom. If you let yourself go deeply enough, you are no longer in a performance but you are actually her for just a brief moment. I remember being so involved in the character that I forgot I was singing. My mind snapped back to reality and I realized, ‘Oh, you are in a performance…you should keep singing’ and I went on with the scene.”

Anna Netrebko

"When singing Lucia's mad scene, I prefer to concentrate more on the bel canto singing than on the acting. Therefore, my mad scene is actually quite steady. I think that too much crazy acting will distract the singer as well as the audience from the right effect." 

Lisette Oropesa

“There are some directors that believe she is mad from the beginning. There are others that say she suddenly snaps because of the severity of the circumstances. I tend to favor the latter. Though I do believe that she has a poetic mind, full of fantasy and is a free spirit, I don't think that makes her any different from many teenage girls of today... The fact is, this abuse from her brother and possibly others might have been going on for many years, and it might not have. We don't know. This is why we have to establish this relationship very clearly in the opera. For me, it's the buildup of events, of course culminating in Edgardo's sudden crash of her sad wedding that makes everything completely reach a breaking point… I believe the final snap actually happens during the finale at the wedding scene. There is a musical moment when everything just explodes and the chorus begins yelling at Edgardo to leave and there is basically a singing frenzy. Lucia is spouting "God-help-me" and it's very intense.

"For me, it's the hardest part to sing in the opera, as a matter of fact! It's often cut it quite short because it's just so taxing… So what's on my mind? It may sound boring but: Technique, breath and keeping my face involved. The goal is to be so vocally secure in the scene that you can pour the greatest part of your focus into your expression of the text and the music. One of the things I try to do is to concentrate on giving the audience my eyes as often as possible, letting them see my face. It puts me in a vulnerable position because it feels very exposed, but that's the case in any aria isn't it?” 

Lyubov Petrova

“Lucia is very much of a singing role so when I have it on my calendar I make sure I have time to review it vocally before rehearsals start. But not only music attracts me in this part, but the dramatic aspect of it as well: There is a young fragile girl who is full of hope who falls into madness. To show this change and make it believable dramatically is a fascinating and challenging journey and that's why I love it.

“This is a woman with a beautiful soul, who wants to love and to be loved, and the world she lives in will not let her do that. So she creates her own reality and in her madness finds happiness. As a part of this journey it is important for me to show this possible alter-reality from the very beginning of the opera though Lucia's vulnerability and vivid imagination. However, the mad scene is unquestionably my favorite part of the opera both vocally and dramatically.

“This is the scene for me when Lucia is finally free and happy and that is what is the most tragic about it. I try to keep it real and fresh every single time, and every time all the craziness has to make sense to me within itself. I incorporate all the vocal challenges into dramatic as Lucia's way of communicating with the world and those challenges help and support each other so I can enjoy every moment of it.”

What goes on in your head when you witness the mad scene from Lucia? Leave your thoughts and impressions in the comments below.

Tags:

More in:

Comments [3]

David from Flushing

There are two more ways to be considered in the performance of "Lucia"---whether to use a flute or Ben Franklin's glass (h)armonica. The second gives a far more eerie sound, though it does not carry well in larger houses.

Sep. 04 2011 06:01 PM
PT

First question: why didn't you include a clip from Natalie Dessay's extraordinary performance?

Second question: why does no one mention that Lucia, this mild obedient young girl has just committed murder? She has stabbed her groom to death as they were about to consummate the marriage. We do not see, but can imagine that he approached her to take advantage of his conjugal rights. He is vulnerable. She is in a frenzy at the loss of her true love by treachery. She sees her husband as part of the betrayal (he is). As he attempts to embrace her, it must feel to her like rape. She doesn't lose her mind; she is in a frenzy of rage that has been building through the opera and it is released in one bloody moment of slaughter. He is defenseless, since he just expects to make love to her. Then she cannot face what she has done and falls in delusion. So it makes sense psychologically and anyone who plays the part would be missing a lot if they did not soak in the implications along with the blood.

Sep. 04 2011 11:15 AM
Gev Sweeney from Ocean Grove, New Jersey

Alas, what goes through my mind is how silly, contrived and embarrassing the scene is! It's a showcase for singers, nothing more. I like Anna Netrebko's approach. The less "mad" acting, the better.

Sep. 04 2011 06:59 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Follow WQXR 

 

 

 

 

 

Sponsored

About Operavore

LISTEN TO THE OPERAVORE 24/7 STREAM

Operavore is WQXR's digital 24/7 audio stream, blog and weekly radio show devoted to Opera. The Operavore blog features breaking news, expert commentary and reviews by writers Fred Plotkin, David Patrick Stearns and Amanda Angel. The stream features a continuous, carefully programmed mix of classic and contemporary opera recordings. The Operavore radio show on WQXR, features opera news bulletins from the around the globe, previews of new recordings, and interviews with the players and personalities on the scene.

Follow Operavore 

Feeds