Risky Business

Tuesday, September 06, 2011 - 12:00 AM

Like most of southeastern Sicily, Modica’s landscape is dictated by the alternating slopes and sharp crags of the Hyblaean Mountains, which carve the comune into a series of steep and narrow streets forming upper and lower levels perfect for burning off Modican chocolate and treacherous for navigating a vehicle.

With Italy on the whole having some of the highest auto crash statistics it’s unsurprising, even in a county where any traffic-related activity takes a certain degree of sprezzatura. Helmet laws were finally enacted over a decade ago. On the first day regulations went into place, a March 31, 2000 New York Times article reported 890 tickets given by mid afternoon in Naples, and while Roman motorcycle parts store owner Maurizio Polidori reported five customers coming into his shop on the same day all holding tickets, he added that “people make a point of honor to flout the law” and didn’t expect the enforcement thereof to last long.

Yet, had tenor Salvatore Licitra been wearing his helmet when navigating the streets of Modica, he might be alive today. His risk of fatal injury was doubled without a helmet in place, and his girlfriend—who was wearing a helmet when their motor-scooter crashed into a wall—escaped with only minor injuries. A study published in 2003 on the Effect of Italy’s motorcycle helmet law on traumatic brain injuries (TBI) showed that TBI was reduced by 66 percent in motorcycle-moped crashes, and there were 31 percent fewer TBI admissions to neurosurgery thanks to the law and police enforcement.

ModicaAnd therein lies the outrage associated with the star tenor’s death: Maybe at the front of the bike, Licitra would have sustained more injuries than his partner even if he were wearing a helmet. It's possible that he may have still died if, as his doctors believe, he suffered a cerebral hemorrhage while at the wheel.

Perhaps, as his brother has stated, Licitra was only moving his scooter a few hundred yards away to park at a restaurant. Maybe his girlfriend forgot her helmet and he, acting out of chivalry, gave her his. But for a singer of Licitra’s stature, neither of these possible explanations should be excuses. He should have known better.

“There’s a really good saying in the motorcycle world, the acronym is ATGATT which is ‘All the Gear, All the Time,’” explains tenor and motorcyclist Ryan MacPherson, who wears a helmet and protective clothing each time he rides his bike. “Even in a 20-mile-per-hour crash, if you fall face first, it’s like a cheese grater.” MacPherson is quick to note, though, that even with an obsessive eye for protective gear, “you can’t prevent a deer jumping out in front of you” (an occupational hazard, particularly in areas like Glimmerglass—where MacPherson has sung—with winding roads, dangerous curves and stretches of highway without street lights).

Like all humans, opera singers take risks, even if it’s something as minor as jaywalking in New York, or more major, like smoking even while fully aware of the health risks. But for the most part, singers are smart enough to mitigate those risks while at work. Many company contracts even contain clauses that prevent singers  from engaging in high-risk activities like bungee jumping, skiing or ice skating.

“If you have a show opening Friday night and…Thursday is also karaoke night and you bust your voice singing Journey all night, you’re in breach of contract. If you can do both, fine. But more than likely, you’re going to be tired and not giving your best performance,” says MacPherson. “You just play with fire when you do that sort of thing.”

Accidents happen, of course. MacPherson recounts being in St. Louis for work when a fellow singer broke his arm playing a casual game of football with several other cast members. There’s the famous case of mezzo Joyce DiDonato fracturing her fibula onstage during a production of Il Barbiere di Siviglia in London and continuing the run of the show from a wheelchair.

And yes, while we may never know what actually happened at the wheel, we can assume Licitra did not deliberately steer his motor-scooter into a wall. However, it’s harder to make a case that the singer going without a helmet was as accidental.

“We have to not be singers or not be artists at some point in our life,” MacPherson says. But where does that point come? Licitra did not have an engagement in Sicily, but does that excuse him from breaking an Italian traffic law by not wearing a helmet? Is it any safer to smoke three packs a day, as Caruso once did? And is seeing a soprano belt out Starland Vocal Band the night before singing Stella in Les Contes d’Hoffmann any worse? And what of the less obvious risks that come with overextension, overworking and eventual exhaustion?

Just as a violinist wouldn’t send their Stradivarius down a ski slope, singers do have a responsibility to their instrument. It’s an even greater responsibility, too, when your body and your instrument are inextricable. Yes, Licitra’s death is sad. Yes, it’s a talent that is gone too soon. But while we can be upset, it’s dangerous to ignore the possibly preventable cause of his death. And that should make us upset in an entirely different way.

How much responsibility does a singer have to their body-instrument, and by extension their audience? Should companies have restrictions on their singers’ extracurricular activities? And, on the flip side, when does being cautious cross the line into being paranoid? Leave your thoughts in the comments below.

Photo above: City of Modica.


More in:

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Comments [11]


the truth is that Mr. Licitra was ill at the moment of the accident and he lost the control of the scooter. his girlfriend was on the scooter as him-WITHOUT HELMET!

May. 29 2012 05:27 AM
marchesa from new mexico

What about the responsibility that opera companies and loved ones have to protect beloved singers? Licitra should not have been allowed to operate a motorbike without a helmet, by anyone. And why wasn't he flown to a major hospital? It all seems suspicious.

Sep. 25 2011 12:54 AM

What about the responsibility that opera companies and loved ones have to protect beloved singers? Licitra should not have been allowed to operate a motorbike without a helmet, by anyone. And why wasn't he flown to a major hospital? It all seems suspicious.

Sep. 24 2011 11:16 PM
concetta nardone from Elmont, NY

Please let us not blame the victim.

Sep. 10 2011 10:50 AM
Barry Owen Furrer

I would like to believe that Mr. Licitra acted out of the love and compassion he had for his girlfriend and insisted that she wear his helmet for protection. Any gentleman would do the same, yes?

Sep. 07 2011 10:06 PM
Jamie from Brooklyn NY

Two of my passions are opera and sportbikes - a rare combination, but it does have the benefit that finding curbside parking for my Honda CBR at Lincoln Center is always a breeze.

Mr. Licatra was an adult, who knowingly accepted the risk involved with helmetless riding. That risk includes the possibility of leaving behind a grieving family. I do not agree with his decision to ride helmetless, but I accept that it was his to make. No doubt many people would be equally critical of my decision to ride in NYC traffic, even with full protective gear.

Those of us who only knew him through his art have no claim on him beyond the expectation that, when we buy a ticket to his performance, he be physically, emotionally, and intellectually prepared and give an honest effort, which to my knowledge he always did, and then some.

I am grateful to Mr. Licatra for sharing his art with us, and I extend my condolences to his loved ones. It seems to me that no other responses are appropriate at this time.

Sep. 07 2011 01:14 PM
Cynthia from NJ

I'm very disappointed to read this insensitive and ungracious post. I would rather celebrate Mr. Licitra's talent and his gift to the opera world.

Sep. 07 2011 12:10 AM
Laurie from Alassio, Italy

I agree with Booksnewyork and I quote:

"How ungenerous for WQXR to post this Olivia Giovetti piece on the day after Licitra's death. Not the time to "blame the victim", and this classical music station is not the place for an editorial comment that "he should have known better".

Let music lovers first hthis post is in very bad taste, ave at least a moment to absorb the loss of a much admired singer.

It's not about the loss of an ARTIST or the loss of a SINGER, it's about the loss of a HUMAN BEING, and it's not the moment to blame or incriminate. Does one imagine that the family is not doing enough of this on their own at the moment without the rest of the world chiming in with "what ifs"????

And yes, he was a pretty amazing human being, a ray of sunlight and goodness to all who knew him.

Sep. 06 2011 04:52 PM
David from Flushing

Motorcycles and scooters have long had the nickname of "slow suicide" and risk appears to be part of their attraction. Prudence applies to all of us in our daily lives.

In this particular case, however, it seems the driver was stricken while riding and had the accident on that account.

I had a friend who suffered a sudden fatal heart attack while driving and crashed his car. It is not always obvious what happens first. Seniors often fall when their hips break rather than falling and suffering a break.

Sep. 06 2011 03:30 PM
John Petrozino from Jackson Heights, NY

Having just survived a cycling accident involving a moving pick-up truck, I can attest to the importance of wearing a helmet! (Mine had cracked all the way through, after having landed on my back-side and hitting my head against the ground.) I get the sense from reading several of his obits that he was fairly cavalier at this point in his life. Not that there are any excuses why one should ever be on or in a vehicle without the proper safety equipment, but we are all guilty of occasional lapses in judgment. At the end of the day, we're only human, and Licitra was a pretty darn amazing one.

Sep. 06 2011 02:55 PM

How ungenerous for WQXR to post this Olivia Giovetti piece on the day after Licitra's death. Not the time to "blame the victim", and this classical music station is not the place for an editorial comment that "he should have known better".

Let music lovers first have at least a moment to absorb the loss of a much admired singer.

Sep. 06 2011 01:59 PM

Leave a Comment

Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.

Follow WQXR 


About Operavore


Operavore is WQXR's digital 24/7 audio stream, blog and weekly radio show devoted to Opera. The Operavore blog features breaking news, expert commentary and reviews by writers Fred Plotkin, David Patrick Stearns and Amanda Angel. The stream features a continuous, carefully programmed mix of classic and contemporary opera recordings. The Operavore radio show on WQXR, features opera news bulletins from the around the globe, previews of new recordings, and interviews with the players and personalities on the scene.

Follow Operavore