The Top 10 Politically-Charged Moments in Verdi's Operas

Operavore

Thursday, September 29, 2011 - 03:45 PM

Being half-Italian, I have a genetic predilection for Giuseppe Verdi, one heightened by the fact that several of my ancestors worked first-hand with the composer in his orchestras and opera productions (I found a note from him to one of my ancestors in a library in Bologna about the trumpet solo in "Celeste Aida" prior to the work's Milan premiere, while great-great-something–uncle Luigi Giovetti was a violinist and dance instructor heavily into Joe Green during the Italian reunification).

So there is something that strikes me every time the chorus of Hebrew slaves reach "Va pensiero" in Nabucco, now playing at the Metropolitan Opera with the next performance on Saturday. Verdi was a musician first, but his nationalistic political leanings followed closely: "Viva VERDI" in Italy in the 1860s was an acronym for "Vittorio Emanuele Re D'Italia" or (Victor Emmanuel, King of Italy). "Va pensiero" was immediately adored by its Milanese audiences, who at the time of the work's premiere were still occupied by the Austrian army.

Politics pervade many an opera—from Lully's Atys to Adams's Nixon in China. However, perhaps no composer can match Verdi for the sheer number of politically-charged moments in opera. My top 10 picks are below, but tell us: What are your favorite political moments in Verdi (or any other composer's canon)? Leave your picks in the comments below.

10. Finale, Un ballo in maschera

This was the finale to invoke the rage of the censors in Verdi's time, namely because it depicted the murder of a monarch onstage. The political intrigue pales in comparison to the love story here (which is heightened oh-so-slightly in comparison to the real-life murder of King Gustav III), however when Ballo is transported from Verdi's substitute of Boston to its intended Swedish setting, you get a new understanding of regicide. The opera has two additional surrounding political intrigues: President Lincoln saw it four years prior to his own, similar, assassination, and it was the opera that Marian Anderson sang when she became the first black singer to appear with the Metropolitan Opera.

9. Finale, Rigoletto

Rigoletto isn't the first opera you may think of when you think Verdi and politics. In fact, it beat out some works with more overt themes about governmental relations (which are at the heart of the painfully-excluded Aida, you can hate on me all you want for that one but I stick by my guns). However, consider the first time you encountered Rigoletto, not knowing anything about the work: How horrifying and heartbreaking was it that Gilda died in the Duke's place and Rigoletto cries out "la maledizione!"? You think the little guy is going to avenge himself and his brethren (Monterrone) against the Man, but because the Duke is just that—a man of political power—he is allowed to get off Scott-free for his antics. And that's the real tragedy. His reprise of "La donna è mobile" is blood-boiling.

8. "Questa dunque è l'iniqua mercede," I due Foscari

One of Verdi's rarer gems, the central theme of I due Foscari is about one man's split duties as father and Doge, and his inability to catch a single break (unlucky fathers seem to be a central theme in Verdi's oeuvre). Francesco attempts to exonerate his son from a crime, then to allow his son's family to join him in exile. After his son leaves Venice, Francesco learns of his innocence, then learns of his death and then is told by the Council of Ten that he should step down as Doge. He launches into this scena full of pathos—lamenting the thanks that he gets for being a ruler first and a family man second—before shuffling off his own mortal coil.

7. "Non giusta causa…Dio non lo vuole," I Lombardi alla Prima Crociata

I could go into detail on this aria, but the subtitles on the below video (with the striking Lauren Flanigan singing the role of Griselda, who has just discovered that her family was killed by the Crusaders) speak for themselves. It's eerie to consider how much lines like "You covet the wealth of the Muslims/This is not heaven's desire!" still ring true today.

6. Act IV, Scene i, Macbeth

It's hard to pick the best moment here: Sure, Nabucco boasts the best chorus of oppressed countrymen, but Macbeth comes in at a close second with a scene featuring not one but two choruses ("Patria oppressa" and "La patria tradita") bookending Macduff's vow of vengeance ("Ah, la paterna mano"). It makes one nostalgic for the time when taking your country back wasn't just a sentiment reserved for Tea Parties.

5. Prologo, Attila

Attila isn't the most exciting of Verdi's operas—especially when it's done with a set that includes a blue tarp—but it did cause quite a stir almost from the get-go upon its 1846 premiere. The opening chorus sings of a conquered city designed to rise, phoenix-like from the ashes. When the conquering Hun makes his entrance, he is confronted by Odabella who asks why his women stay home while Italian women are brave and badass and take up where their male colleagues leave off. Finally, Ezio and Attila share a duet in which the former proposes a deal with the latter, the crux of which being: "Avrai tu l’universo, resti l’Italia a me!” ("You can have the universe, but leave Italy to me"). Understandably, the Austrian-occupied Milanese went crazy for this line.

4. "Plebe! Patrizi! Popolo!", Simon Boccanegra

Boccanegra is a politically tense opera with a Ballo–like plot to kill the title character and a Trovatore–style revelation about one character's actual family. Some of the tension, however, is cut in the finale of Act I when Boccanegra, whose session in Senate is interrupted by a bloodthirsty mob, redirects the crowd's rage. You can hear that coolness come in with the violins and Amelia's waves of coloratura at the end, but since this is just the first act of the opera, you know plenty more upheaval awaits. This is just the calm before the storm.

3. "Per me giunto…O Carlo, ascolta," Don Carlo

Bromance and bureaucracy combine in the über-political Don Carlo, and Rodrigo's death scene gives a little taste for both dishes: First he offers to take the onus of treason off of his friend, Carlo, and falsely confess to the deeds himself, knowing that with his self-sacrifice he'll be saving his friend. Before he can do so, he's shot and, dies happy knowing that he has given Spain a political savior. In his parting words, delivers the moving farewell aria with the chilling and galvanizing line "Salva la Fiandra!" ("Save Flanders!")

2. "In alto mare" and "O tu Palermo," I vespri siciliani

There's no sense in trying to pick one aria over the other when you can compare the two in this opera, originally written for France and, conversely, depicting the French as evil oppressors of 13th-century Sicily. In the first act, a mourning Sicilian Elena is coerced by several drunken French soldiers to sing. This act of misogyny turns into a call to arms from Elena to her compatriots, with a stirring chorus of "Corragio, su corragio" that subsequently incites the oppressed onlookers to riot. It gives heft to the strength of characters, and is anchored in the following scene by the exile Procida's lament upon returning to his homeland without aid to rebel against its foreign occupiers.

1. "Va pensiero," Nabucco

No great surprise here, just great music—indeed, music so great that this is still proclaimed as Italy's unofficial national anthem (it was performed at the 2006 Olympics in Torino). Earlier this year (the 150th anniversary of Italy's reunification), Riccardo Muti conducted Nabucco in Rome and, following a characteristically stirring rendition of this chorus, encored it—pausing to tell the audience that, in light of the ongoing cultural issues in Italy, the line "O mia patria, sì bella e perduta" ("Oh my country, so beautiful and lost") was still a jarringly germane line over a century and a half since it was first sung. The full video is below. Watch it and weep.

Tags:

More in:

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Comments [5]

Thomas

The chilling confrontation between the King and the Grand Inquisitor in Don Carlo is one of my favorite moments in opera.

Sep. 13 2013 12:54 PM
Camilla from Parma, Italy

Just a note: the whole of "Viva VERDI!" (including the 'viva' in the translation) means "Long live Victor Emmanuel, King of Italy!".

Camilla

Sep. 12 2013 05:12 PM
David from Flushing

One might read an anticlerical theme into the outburst of Amneris in Aida when she curses the priests and calls down the vengance of heaven upon them:

Empia razza! anatema! su voi
La vendetta del ciel scenderà!

Oct. 01 2011 06:19 PM
concetta nardone from Elmont, NY

How could I forget Nabucco. Very painful to hear this because right now there is a group in northern group in Italy called the Lega Nord who hate the south and want to secede. Their symbol is the chariot which is called the caroccio. The chariot of the barbarians I say. According to Goethe, who wrote years ago, there is no Italy without Sicily and when you think of Italy, you think Mediterranian. This Lega Nord reminds me of our Tea Party who hate everything, are against everything and who fail to say what they are for.

Sep. 30 2011 02:02 PM
concetta nardone from Elmont, NY

My mother was Sicilian, so dunque I love the Sicilian Vespers, especially the mass murder at the end of the opera. Macbeth is wonderful with its political overtones. The tyrant who is responsible for the murder of Macduff's children and his hearbreaking aria that he was not there to protect them. Aida also has great political fire when Amonosaro narrates the slaughter of his people. But I Lombardi is a DOG, bow wow. How the Moslem becomes a christian and comes back as a saint, yada yada. What a confusing libretto. I think that is what the libretto is about. Bow wow, woof woof.

Sep. 30 2011 11:31 AM

Leave a Comment

Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.

Follow WQXR 

Sponsored

About Operavore

LISTEN TO THE OPERAVORE 24/7 STREAM

Operavore is WQXR's digital 24/7 audio stream, blog and weekly radio show devoted to Opera. The Operavore blog features breaking news, expert commentary and reviews by writers Fred Plotkin, David Patrick Stearns and Amanda Angel. The stream features a continuous, carefully programmed mix of classic and contemporary opera recordings. The Operavore radio show on WQXR, features opera news bulletins from the around the globe, previews of new recordings, and interviews with the players and personalities on the scene.

Follow Operavore 

Feeds