The Fine Line Between Accelerometer and Accelerando

Monday, November 21, 2011 - 10:30 AM

Being a child of the ‘80s, I was born into a group of peers that were less interested in watching laser discs of Joan Sutherland and more game to save Princess Toadstool from the clutches of Bowser.  

For a time, it seemed like Mars and Venus. On Saturdays, my classmates played games manufactured in Japan while I went with my mother to see operas set in Japan and never the twain would meet. But by the time I was 17, I became a Grand Theft Auto addict thanks to my high school boyfriend and his observation that, when you stole a car, you could hear a radio station that played only opera (tooling around in a heisted vehicle while listening to the Champagne aria from Don Giovanni was, incidentally, the perfect way to offset college application stress).

In a refrain as timeless as the Brindisi from La Traviata, parents often caution against many video games, GTA included, for being “too violent.” However, opera—no matter how bloody—is encouraged as a cultural stimulant. That may be, but video games represent at the turn of this new century a means of choose-your-own-adventure opera. Why watch Belmonte rescue Konstanze when you can be Mario saving the Princess? Why hear Tosca shout “Muori, damnato, muori!” when you can shout the same at the green pigs in Angry Birds? Why listen to the connecting intricacies of a Philip Glass score when you can manifestly connect those same cogs yourself in Tetris?

It sounds harsh, but perhaps it softens the bloody tendencies of video games more than it cheapens the sentiment of opera. At their best, both are grandiose, explosive, immersive and obsessive. As later generations have become more interactive by default (see: Twitter, Facebook, comments sections and the like), opera thank the Wii or Xbox as a way of allowing the genre to be handled and manipulated by novices. Many of the more artful games have all of those gesamtkunstwerk elements, from movement and dramatic arcs to striking images to exceptional music.

It’s the music that draws the sharpest comparisons. As composer Philip Glass said in an interview for the NEA about the crumbling boundaries between opera and other musical art forms, “What we're finding in the younger generation is an ease with which a young [composer] can say, 'Well, I do video game music.' And at the same time they'll say, 'Would you like to see my new symphony?'” Today, people know by heart the themes to Tetris or Super Mario Bros much in the way Praguers hummed Le Nozze di Figaro or Italians strolled down the strada whistling Verdi. Final Fantasy VI even has a well-known opera scene, the genre weaving itself into the game’s 19th-century setting and structure.

With a newly released album, the London Philharmonic Orchestra amplifies these connections in The Greatest Video Game Music. The album concept, on first glance, may seem a bit cheesy—not to mention the cover art; a nod perhaps to the cellist of Sarajevo?—but the music is immensely listenable. The Angry Birds theme owes much to Dvorak and Brahms, the title theme from Tetris is a Cold War-style rhapsody, underwater music from Mario flows with the grace of a Lehár waltz, "One Final Efford" from Halo 3 is a lost Bartók piano concerto tempered with Copland-esque Americana, and the "Modern Warfare Main Menu Theme" from Call of Duty 4 is a work worthy of the International Contemporary Ensemble. Hearing it played by a full orchestra, one wonders when Domingo may add the character of Link from The Legend of Zelda to his ever-expanding repertoire.

Operas and video games: Is the connection a 1-up or a game over? Leave your thoughts in the comments below and take our poll:


More in:

Comments [6]

WoS from NJ U.S.A

I love classical music, and I love gaming. Music is music man. I don't see why some music should be banned from given their best presentation possible. 25th anniversary Zelda concert would excite me just as much as a Brahms.

Nov. 22 2011 07:43 PM
Kate from New York

As a gamer and an opera fan, I would love to see video game music performed in our concert halls. If you ask any Zelda fan what their favorite part of the games are, you'll probably get someone gushing about Koji Kondo's beautiful music, especially for 'Ocarina of Time'. Some of my favorite classical compositions are actually Ben Houge's arrangements for 'Arcanum'. It's mostly string quartet and fits right in with the game's 19th century influences. I'm glad this post has gotten such a positive reaction. Did you know there's a mission in 'Hitman: Blood Money' where you can join the superlatives in act three of 'Tosca' so Cavaradossi is actually assassinated? Love it. I only found out the other day that John Adams' music is used in Civilization 4. It's going both ways! :)

Nov. 22 2011 11:59 AM
Chris Richardson

I pretty much only listen to classicl, but am an avid gamer, and can say that without a doubt, there are games that have music that will hold their own. Most notably, the Final Fantasy series (as mentioned in other comments, Uncharted, and the new Skyrim. Uncharted 3 nails the combination of music and gameplay on the highest level - the two go hand in hand to add to an unforgettable experience.

Nov. 22 2011 08:59 AM
Evan Young from New Jersey

Atlanta Symphony doing one of the most famous compositions Nobuo Uematsu has written. You cant argue that dont sound good... And the individual parts are quite difficult. I've seen the original score.

also... another one of my absolute favorites... the opening theme to Final Fantasy 8. Definitely a short masterpiece. Very intense.

Nov. 21 2011 11:57 PM
Evan Young from New Jersey

I agree with Devon Estes. I am a huge fan of Nobuo Uematsu's work. He is one of the biggest reasons why I am a musician today. I owe my love of classical music to that man. If anyone here hasnt heard yet, there are a lot of amazing orchestral transcriptions on video game music. As a child, I played a lot of video games and subliminally, the music helped shape my life. I am what you would call a video game music connoisseur. I collect various albums and I have a TON in my collection dating back to the late 1980s with the Japanese Orchestral Game Music Concert collection. And for kicks, Nobuo and I share a birthday. March 21st. :-)

Here's a video for you guys to get yourselves acquainted.

Nov. 21 2011 11:52 PM
Devon Estes from Brooklyn, NY

Aside from some early choral music by Dowland, Byrd and Bach, I think the music of Nobu Uematsu in the Final Fantasy series was some of the first classical music I got REALLY into. It's good stuff, and really brings the story to a new level of emotion.

Nov. 21 2011 05:53 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Follow WQXR 







About Operavore


Operavore is WQXR's digital 24/7 audio stream and devoted to Opera. The Operavore blog features breaking news, expert commentary and reviews by writers Fred Plotkin, David Patrick Stearns, Amanda Angel and others. The music stream features a continuous, carefully programmed mix of classic and contemporary opera recordings.

Follow Operavore