Long Delayed, Kenneth Branagh's 'The Magic Flute' Arrives in the US

AUDIO: Kenneth Branagh on the Making of the Film

Wednesday, June 05, 2013 - 06:00 PM

Tenor Joseph Kaiser and baritone Benjamin Jay Davis in 'The Magic Flute' Tenor Joseph Kaiser and baritone Benjamin Jay Davis in 'The Magic Flute'

Directors have taken many paths to produce The Magic Flute. Mozart's 1791 opera has been set on the moon with astronauts, in a Wild West saloon with cowboys, and in a hippie commune during the 1960s. When Irish-born actor and director Sir Kenneth Branagh adopted the opera for film in 2006, he gave it another unlikely setting: the trenches of World War I.

In Branagh's version, the Queen of the Night, Mozart's villain, arrives atop a tank. Sarastro, the humane conscience of the story, shelters refugees in a field hospital. Birdman Papageno has his pigeons test for mustard gas in the trenches. The long overture is a CGI-enhanced tracking shot of a scarred battlefield.

Branagh believed that the setting would bring out the epic themes of light and darkness, superstition and reason contained in Mozart’s score and Emanuel Schickaneder's libretto. "I found myself caught with the idea that the poignant and profound conflict of the First World War – with its massive numbers and its extraordinary impact on human life and landscape – might be a terrific crucible for all the elements for this mythic story,” Branagh said in an interview with Jeff Spurgeon (listen to the full conversation above).

“The First World War itself started out as a blaze of patriotism and hope and optimism and [yet] that turned from fairy tale into nightmare swiftly," added Branagh, whose elaborate speech patterns match his background as a Shakespearean actor.

The director jokes that the film’s path to distribution has been equally epic. Although it had limited runs in Europe and in Canada, it has appeared in the U.S. only by way of bootlegs and illicit YouTube videos. But a production company called Emerging Pictures, which focuses on performing arts cinema, took up its cause. This Sunday, it will present screenings in New York and in art house theaters around the country. A DVD and iTunes release is scheduled for Tuesday.

Soprano Amy Carson as Pamina

The film features a new English language libretto by British actor Stephen Fry along with a cast of mainly young singers including tenor Joseph Kaiser (Tamino), bass Rene Pape (Sarastro), soprano Lyubov Petrova (Queen of the Night), soprano Amy Carson (Pamina) and baritone Benjamin Jay Davis (Papageno).

Branagh said that casting was a two-year process with the conductor James Conlon, who leads the Chamber Orchestra of Europe in the film. The producers wanted to find singers who could deliver the vocal goods but also look natural in close-ups. “It took a long time to find a style that could allow for reality and yet meet the demands of the singing,” said Branagh. For preparation, the director had the singers view other opera films, rehearse in front of a mirror and practice improvising scenes on the set.

"The Magic Flute" film started at the behest of Sir Peter Moores, an English philanthropist whose life-long mission has been to promote opera around the world by translating it into English. Seeking to mark Mozart's 350th anniversary year in 2006 he found that Branagh's experience with Shakespeare made him ideally suited for popularizing opera. Moores supplied $27 million in funding and then largely stayed out of the picture.

Although World War I suggests a grim backdrop to this magical tale, Branagh wanted to include some whimsical touches: Tamino is menaced not by a dragon but a rolling plume of gas; a rooster accompanies the Papageno/Papagena duet.

Reviews of “The Magic Flute” have been generally positive if not always ecstatic. The Guardian called it “a genial and good natured production” that “manages to be high-minded and yet accessible.” The Times of London quipped, “this flute blows all right, but it's short on the magic." But North American critics have been more favorable, particularly at its 2009 Toronto screenings.

Would Branagh consider directing an actual opera production someday? "I found myself in a beautifully uncomfortable comfort zone with my friends from opera,” said Branagh of the filmmaking experience. But, he added, “I don’t think I felt comfortable enough to go all the way into the opera house – yet.”

Bass Rene Pape and bass-baritone Rodney Clark in 'The Magic Flute'

Hosted by:

Jeff Spurgeon


More in:

Comments [5]

opuspengie from nyc

This article's images are edited badly. the first image is not from the movie, which would have featured a plume of gas chasing Joseph Kaiser. The caption for the last photo has the wrong singer -- opposite bass Rene Pape is tenor Tom Randall as Monastatos. An the second photo, along with Amy Carson are the sopranos (as the three ladies) Teuta Koco, Louise Callinan, Kim-Marie Woodhouse. I loved this film and I loved the singers -- don't do them a disservice by overlooking or mis-labeling them!

May. 06 2014 09:20 AM
Gina Dodds from New York City

I attended the opening of Branagh's "Magic Flute" and found it absolutely fascinating. The singing, from Metropolitan Opera bass Rene Pape, to the young opera stars, and the chorus, was extraordinary. This version of the Mozart opera classic was cleverly conceived, brilliantly sung and acted, and a film spectacle. The orchestra conducted by James Conlon was magnificent. The 2-1/2 hours--without an intermission--passed so quickly and I emerged from the theatre in a very upbeat mood.

Congratulations to Mr. Branagh, Mr. Fry, and everyone connected to that entertaining film.

Gina Dodds

Jun. 10 2013 12:40 PM
George Jochnowitz from New York

Sarastro is a dictator. He punishes Monostatos for obeying his evil orders, forgetting that he himself was the one who gave the orders. The Queen of the Night is a good guy, until the very end, when she can't take it any more.
Besides, the Queen has the best music. Sarastro, on the other hand, has lots of spoken lines.

Jun. 07 2013 08:56 PM
Kenneth Bennett Lane, Lake Hiawatha, NJ from Richard Wagner Music Drama Institute, Boonton, NJ

Marilyn, it was my typo. I meant to write WW1, which was the most fiercely man to man combat in recent history, similar to our own country's Civil War which pitted brother against brother. With drones and other bombings from aircraft there is no person to person in close proximity occasions to fully sense the obvious inhumanity involved.

Jun. 07 2013 03:19 PM

I'm guessing that it was only a typing error or is it just typical that we Americans get World War I and World War II mixed up all the time. I doubt that you can find a Brit or a Canadian or Austrailian who doesn't know which is which. I am the world's worst typist therefore have no right to criticizs anyone's typing. Fellow readers: don't trust me or my fellow commentator regarding American History and World History. Do your own research on the matter.

Jun. 07 2013 10:38 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Follow WQXR 







About Operavore


Operavore is WQXR's digital 24/7 audio stream and devoted to Opera. The Operavore blog features breaking news, expert commentary and reviews by writers Fred Plotkin, David Patrick Stearns, Amanda Angel and others. The music stream features a continuous, carefully programmed mix of classic and contemporary opera recordings.

Follow Operavore