Barber’s Adagio: The Saddest Piece Ever?

Wednesday, September 08, 2010

It's well known that sad music can have a cathartic effect and help people get through sad times. That explains at least some of the appeal of the Adagio for Strings, a nine-minute lament written in 1936 by the American composer Samuel Barber.

The piece has frequently been chosen to mark occasions of public mourning; it was, for instance, played at the funerals of F.D.R., J.F.K., Albert Einstein and Princess Grace, and has appeared in the scores to a number of films, including The Elephant Man and Platoon. Several memorial concerts in the wake of 9/11 included the work as well.

Even the piece's pop-culture appropriations carry a melancholic tinge, whether the versions by DJ’s and remix artists like DJ Tiësto and William Orbit, or the appearance in a Seinfeld episode. Thomas Larson, author of the new book The Saddest Music Ever Written: The Story of Samuel Barber’s Adagio for Strings told us about "American’s secular hymn for grieving the dead."


There are so many melancholic or tragic classical works -- Chopin's Funeral March, Purcell's Dido’s Lament. Do you feel this is really the saddest piece ever written?

Yes, I do, and I try to make a case for that. I picked this fight. I’ve already had people come up to me and say, 'There’s Schubert, who is much more sad and tragic and so on.' To me, Barber did something as a composer in the composition of sorrow that really tops the list for me. I myself don’t hear anything but the purifying of this emotion in this piece of music. There’s no other thing to call this piece but sad. It’s a lament and an elegy.

Some people claim that it’s simply meditative.

Well, that could be. It is very peaceful and tranquil. But you can’t get away from the slowness and the minor key and Barber’s wonderful way of combining modern harmony with a chant-like modal melody that he does. So yeah, this notion of it being saddest will certainly be argued over. But in my long hearing of lots of different music, I’ve never heard anything that has moved me as much, nor has moved so many audiences.

How did the funeral of Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1945 become the first major public event for this piece?

Barber wrote this as the middle movement of a string quartet and two years later he orchestrated it at [conductor] Arturo Toscanini’s request. The string orchestra version was premiered on the radio in 1938 and in 1943 Toscanini made a recording and that started to circulate. When Roosevelt died, the story goes, deejays looked around for appropriate music because all the regular programming stopped. They had a national grieving for Roosevelt. Radio producers found themselves playing this Adagio over and over again. Barber was catapulted into fame although people didn’t really know him by name. They knew Beethoven and Brahms but not Barber. That began the piece's long treck of association -- its cultural appropriation.

Barber was said to be pretty conflicted about the Adagio's association with funerals. Why? Wouldn’t most composers crave this kind of attention?

I think he was much more disappointed. He always complained that people knew the Adagio but they didn’t know any of his other work. Barber seldom said anything about the Adagio. That’s part of the mystery of it. What we know of it, some comes from Gian Garlo Menotti, who was his partner through much of his life. Menotti famously said Barber would not have been amused by its use in films such as Platoon and The Elephant Man. Barber died in 1981, which was just after The Elephant Man had come out. He knew its memorial associations because it had been played at many funerals beyond the Roosevelt example.

He must have been struck by its use in memorials for John F. Kennedy?

It was one of J.F.K.’s favorite pieces of music and Jackie Kennedy had a concert done the Monday after his death with the National Symphony Orchestra and they played to an empty hall. The concert went out on radio. Barber knew about these memorial occasions and he was kind of a petulant guy. He did a radio interview about it with WQXR when he said ‘they always play that piece. I wish they’d play some of my other pieces.’ (Below: Robert Sherman interviews Barber on "Great Artists" from September 10, 1978.)

You have a chapter called “How to Play the Adagio.” Can a performance be too portentous? What about Leonard Slatkin’s ten-and-a-half minute version from the BBC Proms on September 15, 2001?

It’s difficult to bear the length to which Slatkin puts the piece. He really stretches it out. It was broadcast on the BBC throughout England. There were photographs of masses of people in parks where they turned out. They heard this American conductor conduct the saddest piece in the world on radio and television. Talk about uniting a country in a moment of grief. We can just chalk it up to the moment -- that there are times when a conductor is probably going to linger on those cadences a lot longer than he normally should. Slatkin said it was the most emotional night he’d ever had in the concert hall and listening to it, it’s just a gut-wrenching performance.

You write extensively about the piece's placement in Oliver Stone's Platoon. But there were lighter uses too, as in the offbeat 2001 movie Amélie?

That's where the music is played in this delightful cartoon reality story that happens to this French girl. At one point she turns on the TV and has this dream that she’s the Joan of Arc of modern France. She watches her funeral on television. The announcer is remembering her and she’s watching her funeral and crying and it’s a beautiful, touching, ironic version of the music -- about a minute of it and then it moves on.

With the Adagio parodied in episodes of Seinfeld, The Simpsons and South Park, does that somehow cheapen it? Or can that help Barber's music reach a wider audience?

The vulgar approach is sort of the postmodern approach. That’s important. It often is tough to watch once you have all of these other associations -- to grief, to national funerals, to 9/11. The thing I find interesting is this panoply of adaptation that the piece has gone through – all the way to a disco dance party mix that is probably the most popular version on Youtube. DJ Tiësto -- he's a Dutch DJ that does these huge raves -- he’s done this incredible version, this electronic mix with synthetic beats and so on. Music is really in the ear of the beholder.

Interview has been condensed and edited

What piece of music do you find to be the saddest ever? Post your choice below in our comments area.


Thomas Larson


More in:

Comments [16]

Lawrence Kaiser from Bergen County, NJ

As a connoisseur of sad music, it's at the top of my list (I've sung the a capella choral adaptation of it--devastating), but among the handful of others is the Gorecki 4th, the Albioni 'Adagio', V-Williams 'theme on Thomas tallis' mentioned by someone above. . . moments of bach of mahler, of verdi and Puccini, Chopin's precious Nocturnes, Tchaicovski. . . .after a while, with all due respect, it becomes a silly question, like all "best" s and "first's

Jun. 18 2016 08:25 PM
James Robiscoe from Sleepy Hollow, NY

I agree with all of you, Barber's Adagio is splendid on a spectrum of personal responses. I was 16 when I first heard it (on the Ormandy/Philadelpia record) and through many decades it has been a special support for special moods. I first heard Vaughan-Williams's Tallis Fantasia during this period as well. I find both truly soul-to-soul conveyance of the human (existential?) experience, melancholic, restless,vital, holding on to hope that brings peace...
My vote to add as sad is Elgar's "Sospiri".

Jun. 18 2016 01:39 PM
Les from Miami, Florida

My feeling when hearing the Adagio is one of deep meditation, not sadness. It ends in the major mode, which to me, signifies hopefulness, or at the very least, acceptance. One might also feel sad when hearing Mahler's "Adagietto" from his Fifth Symphony, but in reality it was a love letter to Alma. If beauty is in the eye of the beholder, then sadness is in the mind of each individual listener.

Jun. 18 2016 08:41 AM
Sanjeev Verma from New Delhi

Seven minutes of pure divinity, of unbearable emotion and sadness - that's the Adagio from Mozart's 23rd Piano Concerto in A Major, Köchel 488' for me. It is music that moves me to tears every time I hear it. During those seven minutes nothing else matters but the sound of the piano in that ethereal dialogue with the strings and woodwinds of the orchestra. It is music that I would like played when I am on my deathbed, ready to depart the world. It is the world's farewell sound I would like to carry with me. Forever.

Mar. 05 2015 12:43 PM
Joaquin Tall from SoCal

One of my favorite compositions is Strauss' "Four Last Songs"; "Fruhling", "September", "Beim Schlafengehn" and "Im Abendrot".

Of all those sopranos, who lend their maleficent voices to this wonderful and masterful set of songs, written close to the end of the composer's life, I prefer Dame Kiri Te Kanawa's version. See what you think.

Nov. 28 2014 04:15 PM
Flambeau from Boston, MA

I have been partial to Edward Elgar's Cello Concerto in E minor, Op. 85 since first hearing it in Hillary & Jackie. Definitly a poignant piece coming at the end of WW I that emotes waves of sadness, finality, and resolve to carry on in its movements.

Aug. 15 2013 09:30 AM
Beverly Sutton Lawrence from Elk River, Maryland

So surprised no one mentioned Maurice Ravel's Pavane for a Dead Princess ...

Aug. 31 2012 06:07 PM

Didn't know there was such a history to this piece. I, of course, just think of Seinfeld.

Oct. 04 2010 08:33 PM
John Moran from Jackson Heights Queens

I first heard Barber's Adagio in 2002 around the untimely death of my brother at age 47.

I was stunned by the music.

It was all hurt, irrevocable loss, the finality of death with no hint of comfort.

Indeed it is the most effective death music ever.

Sep. 12 2010 08:12 PM
Michael Meltzer

Reviewing the whole odyssey of the piece, starting with the death of Roosevelt, you realize that any number of pieces could have made that odyssey, for instance the Rachmaninoff C#-minor Prelude. I'll bet if it had, and Rachmaninoff were alive, he would have distanced himself from discussions like this just as Barber did.
Music expresses much that cannot be put into words, and there's a point where it all becomes so much journalism and actually has nothing to do with the music any more, but with subjective impressions of listeners reinforced by harping on the same aspects, over and over until you can't listen with an open mind any more.

Sep. 12 2010 03:37 AM
Jim Newsom from 71922

I think the Beatles' "A Day in the Life" captures the same hole-in-the-soul genre of the Adagio. Different type and era of music, but the same viscerality. Art, by design, captures the human heart, soul and mind. Art (music, painting, literature) shows us what we already know about ourselves, the world --and each other. A Day in the Life and the Adagio both do this and reveal the things that shape us, wound and kill us. Both pieces of music get us in touch with the melancholia of life itself. And, both compositions are a photograph of our inner natures -- an MRI revealing the sadness of the human heart, while at the same time reminding us that life goes on, and that Hope is not just a town in Southwest Arkansas.

Sep. 12 2010 01:04 AM
Yann Saunders from South Carolina

Perhaps equally as "sad" is Albinoni's "Adaggio," though I have a marked preference for Ravel's "Bolero" that we played at my Mom's funeral, at Christmas, 1988.

Sep. 12 2010 12:26 AM
Kate from NYC

No doubt influenced by the Barber, Arvo Pärt's "A Far Cry": Cantus in Memoriam Benjamin Britten is another string piece that imparts a strikingly similar poignancy.

Sep. 11 2010 02:12 PM
Suzanne from New York

I think the first time I heard the Barber Adagio was during "The Elephant Man," in fact, so I do associate it with sadness. . . When it comes to 9/11, though, I think more of Vaughan Williams' "Variations on a Theme by Thomas Tallis." Gregg Whiteside, who was WQXR's morning announcer at the time, played it one morning soon after 9/11 happened, and I remember thinking what an apt choice it was.

Sep. 10 2010 11:51 AM
Rich from The Bronx

Sad, not for me. I first heard the work (not knowing what it was) in an episode of Jacob Bronowski's documentary series "The Ascent of Man". I find it not sad but reflecting and soothing. It is a work though that will bring out different emotions at different times or situations. I once read that when Stokowski toured Russia it was the most requested work as an encore. So not just an American work.

Sep. 10 2010 10:55 AM
Michael Meltzer

First, my first hearing of the barber was not a sad experience - I had immediately the sense that the piece was building, and so it built and built and built, the climax being one of the most glorious moments I ever experienced in a piece of music. The Kennedy assassination and all the other stuff came later.
To me, the saddest piece I've ever heard (or played) is the slow movement in F-minor of the Mozart F-major piano sonata, K.280. It's very much like the slow movement of the A-major concerto, K.488, but not so much a showpiece, more introspective. Very sad.

Sep. 10 2010 01:30 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Follow WQXR