A Bumper Crop of Italian Maestros: Part I

Italian Singers May Be Lacking at the Met, But Conductors are Another Story

Wednesday, August 17, 2011 - 08:23 PM

It has been remarked upon with sad frequency that Italy, the nation that gave us opera, has produced very few great opera stars in recent years. In looking at the Met roster for the upcoming season, the wonderful Barbara Frittoli is the only Italian soprano of note. I found no Italian mezzo-soprano on the roster.

Of late, it seems there must be something in the water of Sicily when it comes to tenors. Marcello Giordani has been an exemplary stalwart in the tenor repertory and we would be much poorer without him. There are a couple of European tenors of Sicilian origin: France’s Roberto Alagna and Switzerland’s Salvatore Licitra. The latter was scheduled to sing Ernani at the Met in February but the role is now assigned to Sicilian tenor Roberto De Biasio, who made his company debut in January when he stepped in for an ailing colleague as Gabriele Adorno in Simon Boccanegra. I did not have the opportunity to hear him. Here is an audio clip from that performance.

The peerless bass Ferruccio Furlanetto will be back in three operas (Faust, Il Barbiere di Siviglia, Ernani) and anyone who loves opera should get tickets for those performances. He is one of the greatest artists of our time. He will also appear at the San Francisco Opera next June in Verdi’s Attila. I welcome the return to the Met of the Bolognese bass Carlo Colombara who, in recent years, has chosen to live in Spain, where he finds the political and artistic environment more congenial. We will also see the excellent young bass-baritone Luca Pisaroni in two new productions (Don Giovanni, The Enchanted Island). Born in Venezuela to Italian parents, he had most of his training in Italy and seems to be following in that tradition.

There are a few other talented Italian singers, such as baritone Alessandro Corbelli, appearing at the Met who are not stars but are valuable artists all the same. There seem to be more Italian-Americans, including Matthew Polenzani, Michael Fabiano, Anthony Roth Costanzo, and Marianne Cornetti. Joyce DiDonato, despite her surname, is of Irish origin. 

On another occasion I will address why I believe there has been a drought of great Italian singers before the public today. It is an alarming phenomenon.

Medals for Good Conduct

I have often said that I think the major achievement of the Peter Gelb era at the Met has been a significant improvement in the quality of conducting. And, frankly, without a great conductor an opera performance is banal, so this is a serious matter. The company has had numerous star conductors, including Daniel Barenboim, William Christie, Lorin Maazel and Riccardo Muti, but at least as important has been the fact that, day in and day out, the music-making from the pit has been superb. There is only one conductor who appears with any regularity who I think is not up to the standard, but I will not mention him because it is just my opinion and it seems he is more esteemed by other opera lovers.

Italian conductors have been very important in this renaissance in the pit. They are as conspicuous at the Met as Italian singers are absent. In the coming season, of the 22 conductors on the roster, there are six Italians (Marco Armiliato, Maurizio Benini, Paolo Carignani, Fabio Luisi, Gianandrea Noseda, Donato Renzetti) and two more with Italian roots. By contrast, there are only three Americans: Christie (who lives in Europe), the legendary James Levine and the excellent David Robertson. In recent years, other Italian conductors at the Met have included Roberto Abbado, Riccardo Frizza, Nicola Luisotti, Evelino Pidò, Stefano Ranzani, Carlo Rizzi, and Roberto Rizzi Brignoli. With a bit of research, I am sure I can come up with a few more.

In the coming season, Luisi, Armiliato and Noseda are the cream of the crop. Fabio Luisi (above left), from Genoa, is principal guest conductor of the Met. He is often described as the presumptive heir to James Levine as music director. He has provided sober, assured and musically insightful performances in varied repertory, including many German works, often stepping in at the last moment. In April, he will lead La Traviata (with Natalie Dessay) and the new production of Massenet’s Manon (Anna Netrebko).

A much-loved figure on the podium is Marco Armiliato, also from Genoa, who will lead the Met premiere of Donizetti’s Anna Bolena (again Netrebko) on opening night (Sept. 26). It is always an honor, and considerable recognition, for a conductor to be asked to lead the first performance of the Met season. Understandably, this job has fallen to James Levine for most of the past four decades. Levine will be back on October 13 to conduct the new production of Don Giovanni. Armiliato has been the go-to guy for 17 different Italian operas, including rarities such as Wolf-Ferrari’s Sly and Alfano’s Cyrano de Bergerac. The only foreign-language opera he has led at the Met is La Fille du Régiment, by the Italian Gaetano Donizetti.

Armiliato will be back later in the season for Aïda and Ernani. Unlike Luisi, who conducts repertory from many countries, Armiliato is the mainstay of what used to be known as the “Italian wing” at the Met. These are conductors who specialize in the works of Italian composers and are guardians of the tradition. In them I see the potential for the renaissance of the Italian opera singer. For many years the Italian wing was occupied by Fausto Cleva and, in more recent times, by Nello Santi who is now 80 and made his debut 60 years ago conducting Rigoletto in Padua. Santi led more than 400 performances at the Met between 1962 and 2000. He still conducts often in Zurich and I would love to see him return to the Met for something special, perhaps in 2012 to commemorate the 50th anniversary of his debut. He has so much to teach to younger conductors and, especially, young singers. He is in every sense a grand old maestro.

Milan-born Gianandrea Noseda was until recently the music director of BBC Philharmonic in Manchester and now is the principal guest conductor of Pittsburgh Symphony. He is also the music director of the excellent Teatro Regio in Turin, the only opera company in Italy that can be said to rival La Scala. Noseda recently led a stupendously successful cycle of Beethoven symphonies that set a record in the UK as the most downloaded music produced by the BBC.

He is notable in that he conducts a vast range of repertory but seems to bring his visceral energy and fine musicianship almost entirely to Verdi at the Met (La Forza del Destino, Un Ballo in Maschera, Il Trovatore, La Traviata, with Macbeth next March), though he conducted Lucia di Lammermoor on tour in Japan in June. The exception at the Met was Noseda’s debut leading Prokofiev’s War and Peace. This is less surprising when one learns that Noseda was a protegé of Valery Gergiev and is an outstanding interpreter of Russian music.

Dante Anzolini, an Argentinian of Italian origin, made a superb Met debut in 2008 leading Philip Glass’ Satyagraha, returns with that opera in November. Robin Ticciati, is a British conductor with an Italian surname. Not yet 30, he conducts Hansel and Gretel at the Met this season. He becomes the seventh music director of the Glyndebourne Festival in 2014.

Stay tuned for Part II of this look at the renaissance in Italian conductors.

Photo credits: 1) Fabio Luisi: Sebastian Willnow/AFP/Getty Images 2) Gianandrea Noseda: Chris Christodoulou


More in:

Comments [5]

Fred Plotkin

To Dino, I am just now seeing your comment. It would take me time to research your question, but I do know some of the answers. Claudio Abbado never conducted at the Met, though Roberto Abbado has. I do not think Giulini conducted at the Met, though could be wrong. Ditto De Sabata and Serafin, but don't quote me on that...I would need to check. Toscanini did conduct quite a bit at the Met, often in the same years as Mahler. Golden Age! Daniele Gatti has conducted at the Met intermittently. Riccardo Chailly conducted only once, a new production of Les Contes d'Hoffmann in the early 1980s. Pappano also only once, the new production of the current (though reportedly soon to be past) Eugene Onegin. Believe it or not, reviews for him and the production were mixed, which puts him the company of many great musicians.

Sep. 23 2011 10:59 AM
Dino from Los Angeles, CA

When talking about truly great Italian opera conductors, my soul cries out the names Claudio Abbado and Carlo Maria Giulini. Despite being a relative newcomer in opera appreciation, I don't recall if either one ever conducted an opera at the Met.

And how about deSabata and Serafin or , in the present era, Gatti, Pappano, and Chailly ?

Sep. 01 2011 03:29 AM
meche kroop from MIMA

Gimme garlic on my pasta and garlic in the pit.

Aug. 19 2011 01:42 AM
Jim Lieberthal from Minneapolis, MN

What a wonderful article with tons of wonderful detail, Fred! I must say that I am a huge admirer of Maestro Noseda. I heard his wonderful War and Peace on Sirius and was very excited that the MET had engaged him. His conducting of La Traviata was exemplary! I thought it had tremendous feeling, depth and architecture. When does one usually notice a conductor in TRAVIATA! Never, unless it's Toscannini...I would say. Just an opinion. Yet his tender handling of the whole opera truly inspired me. And I was so happy, having grown up loving Cleva and Santi. Thank you for the wonderful appreciation of them both. I would love to hear something about Patane too....truly wonderful. These conductors knew and felt everything about the works they conducted and it was always an event that was engaging and breathing...

Aug. 18 2011 11:27 PM
Stephen from Philadelphia

We are blessed to have Ferrucio Furlanetto singing in three different operas at the Met this season. That alone, perhaps, would allow the Met to call itself a world class house. If his performances in Attila, Nabucco and Barber rival his transcendent turns as King Phillip and Fiesco last season, we're in for a treat. Verdi would be thrilled to know he has a compatriot who is showing the world how his music should be sung. Viva Verdi! Viva Ferrucio Furlanetto.

Aug. 18 2011 08:10 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Follow WQXR 







About Operavore


Operavore is WQXR's digital 24/7 audio stream and devoted to Opera. The Operavore blog features breaking news, expert commentary and reviews by writers Fred Plotkin, David Patrick Stearns, Amanda Angel and others. The music stream features a continuous, carefully programmed mix of classic and contemporary opera recordings.

Follow Operavore