When Women Sing More Than One Role in the Same Opera

Monday, August 20, 2012 - 10:07 AM

Regular readers of my articles on the Operavore blog over the past seventeen months will have noticed that I often praise Leonie Rysanek (1926-1998) and promise to discuss her in more detail. If you read Rysanek's obituary in The New York Times by Anthony Tommasini you will get some sense of who she was. I was particularly struck by James Levine’s observation that “She had a fire burning in her at all times...It's remarkable for someone to combine such intensity with a voice of such resiliency and range...Somehow there is a very womanly, soft-textured quality in Leonie's singing, even in its most forceful moments.''

For so many reasons, Leonie Rysanek really was one of a kind. If, in my previous article about singers who evolved to take on multiple roles in the same opera, my focus was on Plácido Domingo, in this case I could point to several great female singers who showed such versatility, but Rysanek will be the foremost example as I will discuss below in her assumption of three roles in Elektra. I promise you another article soon about Rysanek’s greatness in operas in which she only did one role.

Most singers who have done more than one important role in an opera usually specialized in operas by German and Austrian composers. There are more opportunities than in works by Italian composers. While Rysanek, early in her career, did a fair amount of Italian roles and Eva Marton balanced Italian and German parts for most of her career, artists such as Birgit Nilsson, Hildegard Behrens and Waltraud Meier did only a few roles that were not part of the central German canon.  

In many operas by Rossini, Bellini, Donizetti and Verdi, there is the prima donna soprano and, if there is another female role, she is usually a mezzo who is either the lady-in-waiting (to the likes of Lucia or Violetta) or the rival for the love of a man (Giovanna Seymour to Anna Bolena). There are few circumstances in which a singer could go from one role to the other in most operas by these composers. In Bellini’s Norma, the title character is a soprano while Adalgisa has been sung by mezzos (Shirley Verrett) or sopranos (Montserrat Caballé, who sang this role as well as Norma). In 1952, early in her career, Joan Sutherland was Clotilde, the servant to Maria Callas’s Norma, before singing the title role herself more than a decade later.

In Donizetti’s L’Elisir d’Amore, the leading role of Adina and the supporting role Giannetta have been sung by the same soprano (Dawn Upshaw and Nicole Cabell, to name two), with the singer playing Giannetta often being the understudy for Adina.

The Verdian exception is in Aïda, where mezzos such as Verrett and Grace Bumbry have successfully gone from being memorable Amnerises to credible though incomplete Aïdas.  There are a couple of Verdi operas that have two distinct soprano roles though, in each, one is a star and the other is not even seen by the audience. In Aïda, many fine young voices have been heard as the Priestess and some of these went on to major careers. Lucine Amara sang the Priestess at the Met from 1951 to 1953 and then sang Aïda in 1959. Sondra Radvanovsky was the Priestess at the Met from 1997-1999 and finally sang one performance as Aïda there on February 28, 2012. Let us hope she is asked back to do many more.

With Rysanek singing Elisabetta in Don Carlo, on March 14, 1959, a 22-year-old Martina Arroyo made her Met debut in the heard-but-not-seen role of the Celestial Voice. This tiny part is often the launching pad for big careers. On September 20, 1971, Arroyo was Elisabetta on the Met’s opening night, with Domingo as Carlo.

Just as many bass-baritones in Mozart’s Don Giovanni have sung both the Don and Leporello, numerous sopranos, including Carol Vaness and Barbara Frittoli, have sung Donna Anna and Donna Elvira. The roles are both quite difficult and singers who can hit all of Anna’s notes are often asked to play her. Many sopranos find Elvira, with her comic potential, more interesting to play, and her music is very difficult too. Here is Vaness as Anna: 

And as Elvira:

Mozart wrote several other operas with two soprano roles, including Die Entfuhrung aus dem Serail (Kostanze and Blondchen); Idomeneo (Elettra, Ilia); Le Nozze di Figaro (Susanna, Countess Almaviva); and La Clemenza di Tito (Vitellia, Servilia). This last opera also has two trouser roles for mezzo (Sesto, Annio) and many singers (Ann Murray, Sarah Connolly) have sung both, often in the same run of performances. Cosi fan tutte is unusual in that the two sisters are a soprano (Fiordiligi) and a mezzo (Dorabella) while their maid, Despina has been sung by sopranos (Dawn Upshaw) and mezzos (Cecilia Bartoli). This changes the tonal balance significantly and always in interesting ways.

In Die Zauberflöte at the Met, in November 2007, Diana Damrau achieved the rare feat of singing the Queen of the Night  and her daughter Pamina three days apart. 

Evelyn Lear, a great Pamina but no Queen of the Night, was unforgettable as Berg’s Lulu in the 1960s and, by 1980, was doing the Countess Geschwitz in the same opera at the Met as her voice lowered in range.

In Wagner, Waltraud Meier sang the mezzo Brangäne before later becoming a sublime Isolde in a role that lies higher. Rysanek was a heavenly Elsa in Lohengrin in 1958 opposite the evil Ortud of Astrid Varnay. Eva Marton was Elsa opposite Rysanek’s Ortrud at the Met in the 1980s and later took on the role of Ortrud.  I imagine that Karita Mattila and perhaps Deborah Voigt will leave Elsa behind one day and play Ortrud.

Channeling Mozart, Richard Strauss wrote several operas with more than one great female role, mostly for soprano. Even in operas, such as Der Rosenkavalier, in which one role (Octavian) is for mezzo, the other two roles are accessible to some singers in that the Marschallin is a lyric soprano role and the ingenue Sophie verges on the higher coloratura. This means that a soprano such as Helen Donath, who could sing Sophie in her youth, might go on to the more womanly role of the Marschallin. In other circumstances, certain Octavians can become a Marschallin. The great German mezzo Christa Ludwig was most famous as Octavian but also sang a beautiful Marschallin. I wonder if Joyce DiDonato might one day do the same.

Gwyneth Jones, who was once a formidable Salome, now occasionally performs the role of her mother Herodias. In Die Frau ohne Schatten, Rysanek often sang the Kaiserin opposite the Dyer’s Wife of either Nilsson or Ludwig. Later on, Marton sang the Kaiserin with Nilsson but went on the play the Dyer’s Wife. In Arabella there are two sopranos, the womanly title character and the more girlish-sounding Zdenka, her sister. While an example of a soprano who has done both roles does not immediately come to mind, I am sure there is one.

Strauss’s Elektra has three glorious female roles: the crazed and dramatic Elektra, her co-dependent sister Chrysothemis and their malevolent mother Klytemnestra. Rysanek was unforgettable as all three. Elektra is an incredibly hard role and she wisely never performed it live. She did, however, make a film that is an amazing document of what she could do with the role. Her Chrysothemis was phenomenal, especially with Nilsson as Elektra--only Voigt’s comes close. And Rysanek’s last-ever performance was an extraordinary Klytemnestra in Salzburg facing the Elektra of Behrens.

Here is a total immersion in Elektra with Rysanek in each role:

From the Met (1981) with Nilsson (age 63) in the title role, Rysanek as Chrysothemis and the wonderful Mignon Dunn as Klytemnestra. James Levine conducts.  

The entire 1981 Elektra film with Rysanek in the title role, Catarina Ligendza as Chrysothemis and Astrid Varnay as Klytemnestra. Karl Böhm conducts. 

The entire 1991 Elektra from Orange Festival in France, with Gwyneth Jones as Elektra, Rysanek as Klytemnestra and Elizabeth Connell as Chrysothemis. Marek Janowski conducts.  

Note: This is the second of two articles in a series. Fred Plotkin's related article about men who have played multiple roles in the same opera was published last week.

More in:

Comments [9]

Opera nerd from Vienna

...The soprano who sang Zdenka and Arabella was Lisa della Casa, the most famous interpreter of the title role who nevertheless started off as the younger sister.
Edith Mathis had her debut as Cherubino in "Le Nozze di Figaro", then passed to Susanna which she sang successfully for many years. Later she sang the Countess. In this she equals Rysanek who sang all 3 soprano parts in "Elektra" (she even surpasses her, having sung all 3 parts on stage while Rysanek sang Elektra "only" on record for the film).
Many other sopranos went from Susanna to the Countess, among them such famous Susannas as Mirella Freni and Lucia Popp, the latter having also passed from the Queen of the Night to Pamina in the "Magic Flute".
Sena Jurinac had many of those "double bills" - some successively, some alternating - : Anna and Elvira in "Don Giovanni", Octavian and the Marschallin in "Der Rosenkavalier", Dorabella and Fiordiligi in "Così fan tutte".
Just some examples among many...

Sep. 19 2016 05:53 PM

Another new addition to the list-Patricia Racette as Blanche in Dialogues de Carmelites and looking forward to hearing her soon as Madame Lidoine (and I also think she did both Mimi and Musetta)

Apr. 24 2013 09:38 PM

Christa Ludwig sang Flosshilde & Fricka in Rheingold.
Greindl sang Fafner & Wanderer in Siegfried.
Many sang Fasolt or Fafner & went on to sing Wotan.
Tozzi sang Pogner & Sachs.
Early on Melchior alternated between Herod & Narraboth.
Lorenz sang both Herod & Narraboth.
Adam & Hotter sang Amfortas & Gurnemanz.
Neidlinger sang Kingsor & Amfortas.
Hines sang Fasolt & Wotan.
Harshaw sang Brangane & Isolde.
Shuard & Crespin sang Sieglinde & Brunhilde.
Nilsson sang Ortlinde & Brunhilde.
Modl sang Sieglinde & Brunhilde.
Lindholm sang Sieglinde & Brunhilde.

Oct. 28 2012 01:34 AM

Allow me to add some who sang two roles in the same opera.
A. Varnay sang Sieglinde & Brunhilde.
B. Nilsson sang Sieglinde & Brunhilde at both Bayreuth & the Met.
H. Hotter & David Ward sang Hunding & Wotan
Varnay sang the 3rd Norn & Brun. IN THE SAME PERFORMANCE at Bayreuth.
Nilsson sang 3rd Norn & Brunhilde but not same perf.
A list of men who sang both Sachs & Pogner:
Hotter, Greindl, Adam, Ridderbusch, Rootering & Edelmann.
James Morris sang Amonasro & Il Re.
Nilsson sang Venus & Elizabeth in the same perf. at both Bayreuth & the Met.
The list is endless. There were giants in those days.
McCracken sang the messenger & Radames.
There were a bunch of baritones who sang the 4 villans in Hoffmann. London being the best.
Let'not forget Ramon Vinay who sang Scarpia & Cavaradossi.
but basta.

Oct. 27 2012 08:41 PM
David from Flushing

Handel's Semele, which may or may not be considered an opera, has the roles of Juno and Ino that are often sung by the same person. This is due in no small part to Juno's assuming the guise of Ino in order to convince Semele to make a fatal request.

Aug. 21 2012 04:42 PM
Judith from Brookline, MA

Kenneth, would you once please write about something other than yourself.

Aug. 21 2012 01:30 PM
Kenneth Bennett Lane, Lake Hiawatha, NJ from Richard Wagner Music Drama Institute, Boonton, NJ

Fred, your scholarship and passion for whatever subject you choose to select is unico, using the Italian word for specially unique. I was very lucky to start composing at age 10 and studying the entire Wagner ouevre from Die Fliegende Hollander onward. The Jersey Avenue Main Library in Jersey City, where I lived had the benefit of President Franklin Delano Roosevelt's WPA investment in supporting opera and symphony by providing all the Wagner partiturs, full orchestral scores, and the pianoi/vocal scores of Wagner's last ten operas to libraries and professional organizations. My voice teachers included Met Opera legends Frieda Hempel, Margarete Matzenauer, Karin Branzell, Friedrich Schorr, Alexander Kipnis and John Brownlee. Hempel, a coloratura who starred opposite Caruso in most of his popular Italian and French roles was chosen by Richard Strauss to sing the dramatic soprano role of the Marshallin in the Berlin and in the New York (Met) premieres of Der Rosenkavalier. Strauss had intended Hempel to sing the opera's premiere in the role of Zerbinetta (Ariadne auf Naxos ) with an F above High C which reputably was in her capacity. She regrettably affirmed that circumstances might arise that she could not always count on that note. Strauss transposed the aria downward, a practical solution ! Matzenauer starred opposite Caruso as Delilah, Fides, Amneris and Aida, and with the Wagnerians, Isolde and Brangaene, Brunnhilde and Fricka, Ortrud, Vrenus and Elizabeth, Kundry (the first Kundry at the Met). Karin Branzell, along with Melchior, Flagstad, Schorr and Kipnis were the greatest Wagner combo.
GREATEST LOVE SONGS IN BROADWAY MUSICALS is a 23 selection program choice that I will sing at the New Life Expo at the New Yorker Hotel on Saturday October 20th, with my commentaries on each selection. I am a Wagnerian romantischer heldentenor. My wide vocal range permits me to sing music of the tenor , baritone and bass rep convincingly and aptly. The selections are by Irving Berlin, Richard Rodgers, Frank Loesser, Andrew Lloyd Webber, George Gershwin, Jerome Kern, Cole Porter, Rudolf Friml, Harold Arlen, Frederick Loewe, Burton Lane, Cy Coleman, Mitch Leigh, Jerry Bock, Stephen Sondheim, Victor Herbert, Jerry Herman, Oscar Straus, Joe Darion, Claude-Michel Schonberg, Sigmund Romberg, Hoagy Carmichael, and Ralph Blane. My performances on Broadway, in opera, and in three solo concerts and one Joint Recital in the main hall, Isaac Stern Auditorium, of Carnegie Hall, credentialize my teaching voice production and coaching all the Wagner and Shakespeare roles at the Richard Wagner Music Drama Institute. www. WagnerOpera.com; www.ShakespeareOpera.com; RichardWagnerMusicDramaInstitiute.com

Aug. 21 2012 01:08 PM
Steve Kur

Back in the early '70's, I was lucky enough (I didn't live in NYC then), to travel from upstate and "witness operatic history being made..." I saw "Elektra" with Nilsson, Rysanek and Resnick--can't remember who the conductor was. After the curtain fell, the entire audience jumped to its feet; I don't think I've ever seen a more electric (pun intended) opera performance in my entire life! I also saw Ms. Rysanek in the title role in "Die Frau Ohne Schatten," probably my favorite of Strauss' operas, as I used that opera as a subject of a special report in college, and I know it backwards and forwards as I do most of the other Strauss operas. And yes, also seeing Ms. Voigt in her first Met Chrysothemis was incredible. This was BEFORE 911, so I actually put my name on the backstage list and was lucky enough to be called by the security people to meet her in her dressing room. Long live singers like Nilsson, Rysanek and Voigt, just to mention a few out of many.

Aug. 21 2012 11:15 AM
Francesco from Milano, Italy

Dear Fred, I know space is limited and the list endless, but I would add at least:
-Angela Gheorghiu sung both Micaela and Carmen (as did Anna Moffo and Victoria de Los Angeles)
-Edita Gruberova and Joan Sutherland have sung all three leading female role in Les Contes d'Hoffmann (Antonia, Olympia and Giulietta)
-Shirley Verrett sung both Amelia and Ulrica in Ballo (RCA recording with Leinsdorf and La Scala with Abbado)
-Sopranos who sung both Musetta and Mimì in La Bohème: Renata Scotto, Anna Moffo, Nuccia Focile
-Sopranos who sung both Turandot and Liù: Caballé and Ricciarelli
-Violeta Urmana has sung both Eboli and Elisabetta in Don Carlos
-Barbara Frittoli has sung both Ines and Leonora in Verdi's Trovatore (Florence with Mehta and Milan with Muti)
-Behrens has sung both Sieglinde and Brunnhilde in Walkure
-Agnes Baltsa has sung both Dorabella and Despina in Così fan tutte (and Bartoli did all three female roles, including Fiordiligi in Zurich)
-Bartoli has sung both Cherubino and Susanna in Nozze di Figaro...and of course both Donna Elvira and Zerlina in Don Giovanni. She probably gets the cake of camaleontic female cast member!

Aug. 21 2012 10:12 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

The WQXR e-newsletter. Show highlights, links to music news, on-demand concerts, events from The Greene Space and more.

Follow WQXR 







About Operavore


Operavore is WQXR's digital 24/7 audio stream and devoted to Opera. The Operavore blog features breaking news, expert commentary and reviews by writers Fred Plotkin, David Patrick Stearns, Amanda Angel and others. The music stream features a continuous, carefully programmed mix of classic and contemporary opera recordings.

Follow Operavore